ConceptComplete

Algebraic Spaces

Algebraic spaces were introduced by Michael Artin in the late 1960s as a natural generalization of schemes. They arise when one takes quotients of schemes by étale equivalence relations — a construction that does not always remain in the category of schemes. Algebraic spaces form an intermediate category between schemes and algebraic stacks, and they appear naturally in moduli problems where a fine moduli scheme fails to exist but a coarse moduli space does.


1. Motivation: Beyond Schemes

Many natural constructions in algebraic geometry produce objects that are not schemes. For instance, if GG is a finite group acting freely on a scheme XX, the quotient X/GX/G may not exist as a scheme but always exists as an algebraic space. This motivates the need for a broader category.

The key insight is to work with the étale topology rather than the Zariski topology. In the étale topology, representable functors are sheaves, and algebraic spaces are certain sheaves that are "close to" being representable.


2. The Étale Site

DefinitionBig Étale Site

Let SS be a scheme. The big étale site (Sch/S)eˊt(\mathrm{Sch}/S)_{\text{ét}} is the category of SS-schemes equipped with the étale topology, where coverings are families of étale morphisms {UiU}\{U_i \to U\} such that UiU\coprod U_i \to U is surjective.

A presheaf F:(Sch/S)opSetF: (\mathrm{Sch}/S)^{\mathrm{op}} \to \mathrm{Set} is a sheaf for the étale topology if for every étale covering {UiU}\{U_i \to U\}, the diagram

F(U)iF(Ui)i,jF(Ui×UUj)F(U) \to \prod_i F(U_i) \rightrightarrows \prod_{i,j} F(U_i \times_U U_j)

is an equalizer.


3. Definition of Algebraic Spaces

DefinitionAlgebraic Space

An algebraic space over a scheme SS is a functor X:(Sch/S)opSetX: (\mathrm{Sch}/S)^{\mathrm{op}} \to \mathrm{Set} such that:

  1. XX is a sheaf for the étale topology on (Sch/S)(\mathrm{Sch}/S).
  2. The diagonal Δ:XX×SX\Delta: X \to X \times_S X is representable by schemes.
  3. There exists a scheme UU and a surjective étale morphism UXU \to X (an étale atlas).

Condition (2) ensures that for any scheme TT and any two morphisms a,b:TXa, b: T \to X, the fiber product T×(a,b),X×XXT \times_{(a,b), X \times X} X is a scheme. This means the "overlap" data is always schematic.

Condition (3) says that XX is locally (in the étale topology) a scheme.

Remark

Every scheme is an algebraic space: the functor of points hX=Hom(,X)h_X = \mathrm{Hom}(-, X) satisfies all three conditions, with U=XU = X as the atlas.


4. Equivalent Formulation via Equivalence Relations

An algebraic space can equivalently be described as a quotient sheaf U/RU/R where RUR \rightrightarrows U is an étale equivalence relation on a scheme UU. We will develop this perspective in detail in the next section on étale equivalence relations.

DefinitionÉtale Presentation

An étale presentation of an algebraic space XX is a pair (U,R)(U, R) where UU is a scheme with an étale surjection UXU \to X and R=U×XUR = U \times_X U is the equivalence relation, with both projections s,t:RUs, t: R \rightrightarrows U being étale.


5. Morphisms of Algebraic Spaces

A morphism of algebraic spaces f:XYf: X \to Y over SS is simply a natural transformation of functors. Since algebraic spaces are sheaves on the big étale site, the category of algebraic spaces over SS is a full subcategory of the category of sheaves.

DefinitionRepresentable Morphism

A morphism f:XYf: X \to Y of algebraic spaces is representable (by schemes) if for every scheme TT and morphism TYT \to Y, the fiber product X×YTX \times_Y T is a scheme.

For a representable morphism, we can define properties such as being étale, smooth, flat, proper, etc., by requiring that the base change X×YTTX \times_Y T \to T has the corresponding property for all TYT \to Y.


6. Examples

ExampleSchemes as algebraic spaces

Every scheme XX over SS defines an algebraic space via its functor of points hX(T)=HomS(T,X)h_X(T) = \mathrm{Hom}_S(T, X). The identity XhXX \to h_X is an étale atlas. This embedding Sch/SAlgSp/S\mathrm{Sch}/S \hookrightarrow \mathrm{AlgSp}/S is fully faithful.

ExampleQuotient by a free finite group action

Let XX be a scheme and GG a finite group acting freely on XX (i.e., the map G×XX×XG \times X \to X \times X given by (g,x)(gx,x)(g, x) \mapsto (gx, x) is a closed immersion). Define R=G×XR = G \times X with s(g,x)=xs(g,x) = x and t(g,x)=gxt(g,x) = gx. Then RXR \rightrightarrows X is an étale equivalence relation, and the quotient X/GX/G is an algebraic space. When the action is not free, one must use algebraic stacks instead.

ExampleNon-separated algebraic space: the line with doubled origin

Consider U=Ak1Ak1U = \mathbb{A}^1_k \sqcup \mathbb{A}^1_k and the equivalence relation RR that identifies the two copies away from the origin: R=UGm,kR = U \sqcup \mathbb{G}_{m,k} with appropriate source and target maps. The resulting algebraic space is the "line with doubled origin," which is an algebraic space but not a separated one. Indeed, it is also a scheme — a non-separated one.

ExampleQuotient of the plane by an involution

Let X=Ak2X = \mathbb{A}^2_k and G=Z/2ZG = \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z} acting by (x,y)(x,y)(x,y) \mapsto (-x, -y). The quotient X/GX/G exists as a scheme Speck[x2,xy,y2]Speck[a,b,c]/(acb2)\mathrm{Spec}\, k[x^2, xy, y^2] \cong \mathrm{Spec}\, k[a,b,c]/(ac - b^2). This is a quadric cone, and in this case the algebraic space is actually a scheme.

ExampleAn algebraic space that is not a scheme

Let kk be an algebraically closed field and let AA be an abelian surface over kk. Let ι:AA\iota: A \to A be the involution aaa \mapsto -a. The fixed locus consists of the 16 two-torsion points. Let U=A{0}U = A \setminus \{0\} and G={1,ιU}G = \{1, \iota|_U\}. Since ι\iota acts freely on UU (the other 15 fixed points being blown up), U/GU/G is an algebraic space. However, for suitable choices, one can arrange that this quotient is an algebraic space not isomorphic to any scheme.

ExampleHironaka's example

Hironaka constructed a smooth proper threefold XX over C\mathbb{C} with a free Z/2Z\mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z}-action such that the quotient X/(Z/2Z)X / (\mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z}) is a proper smooth algebraic space that is not a scheme. This is one of the classical examples demonstrating the necessity of algebraic spaces. The key point is that XX is a proper variety, but the quotient, while proper as an algebraic space, does not admit an ample line bundle, and therefore is not projective and indeed not a scheme.

ExampleAffine algebraic spaces are schemes

If XX is an algebraic space admitting an étale atlas UXU \to X with UU affine, and if XX is quasi-separated, then XX is actually an affine scheme. More generally, every quasi-separated algebraic space that is affine over a scheme is itself a scheme.

ExampleAlgebraic space from a non-effective descent datum

Consider a scheme SS and an étale cover {UiS}\{U_i \to S\} with a descent datum for quasi-coherent sheaves that is effective. Now consider the moduli functor that parametrizes descent data. When descent fails to be effective (in the Zariski topology), the resulting functor may be an algebraic space rather than a scheme, witnessing the strictly larger scope of the étale topology.

ExampleThe Hilbert scheme as an algebraic space

For certain moduli problems, the Hilbert functor is representable by a scheme (by Grothendieck's theorem). However, relative Hilbert functors for algebraic spaces, HilbX/S\mathrm{Hilb}_{X/S} where XX is an algebraic space over SS, exist as algebraic spaces. This generalization is due to Artin.

ExampleAlgebraic space structure on analytic quotients

Over C\mathbb{C}, let XX be a smooth scheme and GG a finite group acting properly on XanX^{\mathrm{an}}. By GAGA-type results, if the quotient Xan/GX^{\mathrm{an}}/G is algebraizable, it carries the structure of an algebraic space. The passage from analytic to algebraic often forces one to work with algebraic spaces rather than schemes.

ExampleQuotients by étale group schemes

Let SS be a scheme, XX an SS-scheme, and GSG \to S an étale group scheme acting freely on XX. Then the fppf quotient sheaf X/GX/G is an algebraic space over SS. When GG is a constant finite group, this recovers the earlier example.

ExampleWeil restriction producing algebraic spaces

Let L/KL/K be a finite separable field extension, and let XX be a scheme over LL. The Weil restriction ResL/K(X)\mathrm{Res}_{L/K}(X) is defined as the functor TX(T×KL)T \mapsto X(T \times_K L). When XX is quasi-projective, ResL/K(X)\mathrm{Res}_{L/K}(X) is a scheme. For more general XX, the Weil restriction exists as an algebraic space over KK.

ExampleThe coarse moduli space of curves

The moduli stack Mg\mathcal{M}_g of smooth curves of genus g2g \geq 2 is a smooth proper Deligne-Mumford stack. Its coarse moduli space MgM_g is an algebraic space (and in fact a quasi-projective scheme by the Keel-Mori theorem combined with results on ampleness). For g=1g = 1 with level structure, similar constructions produce algebraic spaces.


7. Comparison with Schemes

The relationship between schemes and algebraic spaces can be summarized as follows:

| Property | Schemes | Algebraic Spaces | |----------|---------|------------------| | Local model | Affine schemes Spec(A)\mathrm{Spec}(A) | Schemes (via étale atlas) | | Topology used | Zariski | Étale | | Points | Spec(k)X\mathrm{Spec}(k) \to X | Geometric points modulo equivalence | | Ample line bundles | May exist | May not exist | | Quotients by free finite groups | May fail | Always exist |

TheoremSchemes inside algebraic spaces

The functor Sch/SAlgSp/S\mathrm{Sch}/S \to \mathrm{AlgSp}/S is fully faithful. An algebraic space XX is a scheme if and only if there exists a Zariski open covering {UiX}\{U_i \to X\} where each UiU_i is an affine scheme.


8. Points of an Algebraic Space

DefinitionPoints of an algebraic space

A point of an algebraic space XX is an equivalence class of morphisms Spec(k)X\mathrm{Spec}(k) \to X where kk is a field, under the equivalence relation generated by: Spec(k)X\mathrm{Spec}(k) \to X is equivalent to Spec(k)X\mathrm{Spec}(k') \to X if there exists a common field extension Spec(Ω)Spec(k)\mathrm{Spec}(\Omega) \to \mathrm{Spec}(k) and Spec(Ω)Spec(k)\mathrm{Spec}(\Omega) \to \mathrm{Spec}(k') making the diagram commute.

The set of points X|X| carries a natural topology: a subset ZXZ \subseteq |X| is closed if and only if p1(Z)Up^{-1}(Z) \subseteq |U| is closed for some (equivalently, any) étale atlas p:UXp: U \to X.

Remark

Unlike schemes, the topological space X|X| of an algebraic space may not be sober (i.e., not every irreducible closed subset need have a unique generic point). However, if XX is quasi-separated, then X|X| is sober.


9. The Diagonal and Quasi-Separatedness

The representability of the diagonal Δ:XX×SX\Delta: X \to X \times_S X is part of the definition. The diagonal encodes how "overlaps" in an algebraic space behave.

DefinitionQuasi-separated algebraic space

An algebraic space XX over SS is quasi-separated if the diagonal Δ:XX×SX\Delta: X \to X \times_S X is quasi-compact. It is separated if Δ\Delta is a closed immersion.

Most algebraic spaces encountered in practice are quasi-separated. The quasi-separated hypothesis is important for many foundational results, including the comparison between the étale and Zariski topologies.


10. Algebraic Spaces and Stacks

Algebraic spaces sit naturally in the hierarchy:

Affine schemesSchemesAlgebraic spacesDM stacksAlgebraic stacks\text{Affine schemes} \subset \text{Schemes} \subset \text{Algebraic spaces} \subset \text{DM stacks} \subset \text{Algebraic stacks}

An algebraic space is the same thing as a Deligne-Mumford stack with trivial automorphism groups. Equivalently, an algebraic space is a DM stack X\mathcal{X} such that the inertia stack IXXI_\mathcal{X} \to \mathcal{X} is the identity.

This perspective is extremely useful: results proven for DM stacks immediately specialize to algebraic spaces, and many techniques (such as the Keel-Mori theorem) go in the reverse direction, producing algebraic spaces from DM stacks.


References

  • M. Artin, Algebraic Spaces, Yale Mathematical Monographs, 1971.
  • D. Knutson, Algebraic Spaces, Lecture Notes in Mathematics 203, Springer, 1971.
  • The Stacks Project, Part: Algebraic Spaces.
  • G. Laumon and L. Moret-Bailly, Champs algébriques, Springer, 2000.