Keel--Mori Theorem: Existence of Coarse Moduli Spaces
The Keel--Mori theorem is the fundamental existence result for coarse moduli spaces of algebraic stacks. It guarantees that every algebraic stack with finite inertia admits a coarse moduli space as an algebraic space, providing the essential link between the stacky world and classical algebraic geometry.
Statement
Let be an algebraic stack locally of finite type over an algebraic space . Assume that the inertia stack is finite (equivalently, the stabilizer group schemes are finite for all geometric points ). Then there exists a coarse moduli space where:
- is an algebraic space locally of finite type over .
- is proper and quasi-finite.
- .
- For every algebraically closed field , induces a bijection .
- is universal: any morphism to an algebraic space factors uniquely through .
Moreover, if is separated, then is separated. If is of finite type and separated, then is of finite type and separated.
The inertia stack parametrizes pairs (object , automorphism ). The condition that is finite means each stabilizer group is a finite group scheme. This includes:
- All DM stacks with quasi-finite diagonal.
- Quotient stacks where is a finite group.
- But not (stabilizer is not finite).
Without the finite inertia condition, coarse moduli spaces may not exist. For , the "coarse space" would need to be , but the universal property fails: there exist non-isomorphic line bundles on some scheme that both map to the same point of .
Key properties of the coarse moduli map
Let be the coarse moduli map from the Keel--Mori theorem. Then:
(a) is initial among morphisms from to algebraic spaces.
(b) The formation of commutes with flat base change: if is flat, then is the coarse moduli space of .
(c) If with finite acting on , then (the geometric quotient, which exists as an algebraic space by Keel--Mori applied to the action groupoid).
(d) The map is a homeomorphism on underlying topological spaces: .
(e) In characteristic zero (or when the orders of all stabilizers are invertible in ): is exact on coherent sheaves, and for and coherent.
Examples
For (), the inertia is finite (automorphism groups are finite by the Hurwitz bound). Keel--Mori gives the coarse moduli space , a quasi-projective variety of dimension . The map is proper and quasi-finite, and an isomorphism over the open locus of curves without extra automorphisms.
For : every genus-2 curve has the hyperelliptic involution, so is nowhere an isomorphism. The coarse space (identified via the six branch points of the hyperelliptic map, modulo the -action by relabeling).
For with finite, the coarse space is . The map sends every -torsor to the unique -point. The pushforward is the functor (taking -invariants).
In characteristic zero, this is exact (Maschke's theorem: is a direct summand of ). In characteristic dividing , the functor is only left-exact, and can be nonzero.
For acting on (type ), Keel--Mori gives . The coarse space has the singularity at the origin, while the stack is smooth. The map is a bijection on geometric points (both have the same underlying set of orbits), but is not an isomorphism at the origin.
More generally, for a finite subgroup (giving ADE singularities), the coarse space has the corresponding surface singularity, and is the "canonical stacky resolution."
For with , the stabilizers are cyclic (hence finite), and Keel--Mori gives the coarse space (the classical weighted projective variety).
For : the coarse space is (the quadric cone). The Keel--Mori map is an isomorphism away from (where the -stabilizer lives) and contracts the -gerbe at to the singular point of the cone.
For , the inertia is finite (stabilizers are , , or ). Keel--Mori gives (the -line). The map satisfies:
- for each -value (the fiber is the residual gerbe).
- .
- The universal elliptic curve exists on the stack but not on .
For , has trivial automorphism groups (a rational curve with marked points is rigid), so the coarse moduli map is an isomorphism: . The compactification is a smooth projective variety, explicitly described as an iterated blowup of .
For : (the cross-ratio). For : (the del Pezzo surface of degree 5).
For the root stack with a smooth divisor in a smooth variety , the stabilizers along are (finite). Keel--Mori gives the coarse space back: The map is an isomorphism over and a -gerbe along .
The stack has finite stabilizers (the automorphism group of a ppav is finite). Keel--Mori gives the coarse space , which over is the Siegel modular variety .
For : . For : is a normal quasi-projective variety of dimension 3, with the Igusa compactification being projective.
Consider , where swaps the two copies of but fixes both origins. The coarse space is the "line with doubled origin" -- a non-separated algebraic space. This happens because itself is not separated.
The stack has stabilizer at its unique point -- this is not finite, so Keel--Mori does not apply. Indeed, there is no coarse moduli space: the universal property would require that every line bundle on every scheme is pulled back from a map . But can be nontrivial (e.g., ), contradicting the pullback requirement.
The "good moduli space" theory of Alper extends the Keel--Mori theorem to certain Artin stacks with non-finite stabilizers, replacing "coarse moduli space" with "good moduli space."
A DM stack is tame if the stabilizer groups at all geometric points have order invertible in the base. The Keel--Mori theorem for tame stacks has the additional property that is exact.
For example, over , any DM stack with stabilizers of order dividing is tame. The stack over is tame (stabilizers have order dividing 6).
In the wild case (characteristic divides the order of stabilizers), the Keel--Mori theorem still gives a coarse space, but the pushforward may fail to be exact.
If is a DM stack with all stabilizers isomorphic to a fixed finite group , then makes into a -gerbe over (in the etale topology). The gerbe class is the obstruction to having a section (i.e., to being a "trivial" gerbe).
For : generically this is a -gerbe (the generic stabilizer is ). The gerbe class in is nontrivial -- there is no universal elliptic curve over the -line.
Proof strategy
The proof of the Keel--Mori theorem proceeds in several steps:
Step 1 (Local construction): Reduce to the case where is an etale groupoid. Then is constructed locally as the coequalizer of in the category of algebraic spaces. The key tool is the existence of quotients by finite flat equivalence relations (due to Artin).
Step 2 (Finite flat closure): Replace the etale groupoid by a finite flat equivalence relation by taking the "schematic image" of in . This requires the finiteness of the inertia.
Step 3 (Gluing): Glue the local constructions using the universal property and descent.
Step 4 (Properties): Verify that satisfies the universal property and the bijection on geometric points.
The original proof by Keel and Mori (1997) used a slightly different approach via "coarsification"; the above outline follows the treatment of Conrad.
Summary
The Keel--Mori theorem guarantees that any algebraic stack with finite inertia admits a coarse moduli space as an algebraic space. The coarse map is proper and quasi-finite, induces a bijection on geometric points, and is universal among maps to algebraic spaces. This theorem is the cornerstone for connecting the stack-theoretic approach to classical algebraic geometry.