ConceptComplete

Coarse Moduli Spaces

A coarse moduli space is the "best approximation" of a moduli stack by an algebraic space (or scheme). It retains the underlying set of isomorphism classes but forgets the automorphism data. The existence of coarse moduli spaces is guaranteed under mild conditions by the Keel--Mori theorem, and they serve as the bridge between the stack-theoretic and classical approaches to moduli theory.


Definition

Definition4.18Coarse Moduli Space

Let X\mathcal{X} be an algebraic stack over a scheme SS. A coarse moduli space for X\mathcal{X} is a pair (M,π)(M, \pi) where MM is an algebraic space over SS and π:X→M\pi : \mathcal{X} \to M is a morphism, satisfying:

  1. (Universal property) For every algebraic space NN and morphism f:Xβ†’Nf : \mathcal{X} \to N, there exists a unique morphism g:Mβ†’Ng : M \to N with f=gβˆ˜Ο€f = g \circ \pi.

  2. (Geometric bijectivity) For every algebraically closed field kk, the induced map Ο€(k):∣X(k)βˆ£β†’M(k)\pi(k) : |\mathcal{X}(k)| \to M(k) is a bijection, where ∣X(k)∣|\mathcal{X}(k)| denotes the set of isomorphism classes of objects of X\mathcal{X} over Spec⁑k\operatorname{Spec} k.

When it exists, the coarse moduli space is unique up to unique isomorphism.

RemarkCoarse vs fine moduli

A fine moduli space is a scheme (or algebraic space) MM that represents the moduli functor: there is a universal family over MM. This requires X≅M\mathcal{X} \cong M as stacks, which happens only when all automorphism groups are trivial.

A coarse moduli space exists more generally but does not carry a universal family in general. The stack X\mathcal{X} carries the universal family; the coarse space MM is the quotient that identifies isomorphic objects.

The relationship: X→πM\mathcal{X} \xrightarrow{\pi} M is an isomorphism if and only if X\mathcal{X} is an algebraic space (i.e., has trivial automorphisms).


Existence

RemarkKeel--Mori theorem (preview)

The Keel--Mori theorem states: if X\mathcal{X} is an algebraic stack with finite inertia (i.e., the inertia stack IX→X\mathcal{I}_\mathcal{X} \to \mathcal{X} is finite), then a coarse moduli space exists. This applies in particular to separated DM stacks with quasi-finite diagonal. See the theorem page for the precise statement and proof outline.


Properties of the coarse moduli map

Definition4.19Properties of the coarse map

Let π:X→M\pi : \mathcal{X} \to M be a coarse moduli space. Then:

  1. Ο€\pi is proper and quasi-finite (if X\mathcal{X} is separated and of finite type).
  2. Ο€βˆ—:QCoh⁑(X)β†’QCoh⁑(M)\pi_* : \operatorname{QCoh}(\mathcal{X}) \to \operatorname{QCoh}(M) is exact (the pushforward preserves coherence and exactness for coherent sheaves when the characteristic does not divide the orders of the stabilizer groups).
  3. OMβ†’βˆΌΟ€βˆ—OX\mathcal{O}_M \xrightarrow{\sim} \pi_* \mathcal{O}_\mathcal{X} (the structure sheaf of MM is the invariant part).
  4. For a DM stack X\mathcal{X} with generically trivial stabilizer, Ο€\pi is an isomorphism on a dense open.

Examples

ExampleCoarse moduli space of curves

The stack Mg\mathcal{M}_g (gβ‰₯2g \geq 2) has coarse moduli space MgM_g, a quasi-projective variety of dimension 3gβˆ’33g - 3. The map Ο€:Mgβ†’Mg\pi : \mathcal{M}_g \to M_g is an isomorphism on the open locus of curves with trivial automorphism group (which is dense for gβ‰₯3g \geq 3).

For g=2g = 2: every genus-2 curve is hyperelliptic, so Aut⁑(C)βŠ‡Z/2Z\operatorname{Aut}(C) \supseteq \mathbb{Z}/2\mathbb{Z} for all CC. The coarse space M2M_2 has dimension 3 and is rational (birationally equivalent to A3\mathbb{A}^3).

The Deligne--Mumford compactification Mβ€Ύg\overline{\mathcal{M}}_g has coarse moduli space Mβ€Ύg\overline{M}_g, a projective variety. Mumford proved Mβ€Ύg\overline{M}_g is of general type for gβ‰₯24g \geq 24 (later improved by Harris--Mumford to gβ‰₯23g \geq 23, and by Farkas to g=22g = 22).

ExampleThe j-line as coarse moduli space

The stack M1,1\mathcal{M}_{1,1} of elliptic curves has coarse moduli space M1,1β‰…Aj1M_{1,1} \cong \mathbb{A}^1_j (the jj-line). The map Ο€:M1,1β†’Aj1\pi : \mathcal{M}_{1,1} \to \mathbb{A}^1_j sends an elliptic curve EE to its jj-invariant.

Over C\mathbb{C}, Ο€\pi is an isomorphism over A1βˆ–{0,1728}\mathbb{A}^1 \setminus \{0, 1728\} (where automorphism groups are ΞΌ2\mu_2, the minimum). At j=1728j = 1728, the fiber has automorphisms ΞΌ4\mu_4, and at j=0j = 0, the fiber has automorphisms ΞΌ6\mu_6.

There is no universal elliptic curve over Aj1\mathbb{A}^1_j. The obstruction is precisely that M1,1β†’Aj1\mathcal{M}_{1,1} \to \mathbb{A}^1_j is a nontrivial ΞΌ2\mu_2-gerbe generically (every elliptic curve has the [βˆ’1][-1] involution).

ExampleCoarse space of BG

For a finite group GG, the classifying stack BG=[Spec⁑k/G]\mathrm{B}G = [\operatorname{Spec} k / G] has coarse moduli space Spec⁑k\operatorname{Spec} k (a point). The map Ο€:BGβ†’Spec⁑k\pi : \mathrm{B}G \to \operatorname{Spec} k collapses all the automorphism data. Over an algebraically closed field, BG\mathrm{B}G has a unique isomorphism class (the trivial torsor), so the bijection on geometric points holds.

This is the simplest example where the coarse space is smooth but the stack is "non-trivially stacky." The coarse map Ο€βˆ—:QCoh⁑(BG)β†’QCoh⁑(Spec⁑k)\pi_* : \operatorname{QCoh}(\mathrm{B}G) \to \operatorname{QCoh}(\operatorname{Spec} k) sends a GG-representation VV to its invariants VGV^G.

ExampleQuotient singularities as coarse spaces

Let GG be a finite group acting on a smooth variety XX. The quotient stack [X/G][X/G] is a smooth DM stack, and its coarse moduli space is the GIT quotient X/GX/G. When GG acts with fixed points, X/GX/G acquires singularities even though [X/G][X/G] is smooth.

For G=ΞΌnG = \mu_n acting on A2\mathbb{A}^2 by ΞΆβ‹…(x,y)=(ΞΆx,ΞΆβˆ’1y)\zeta \cdot (x,y) = (\zeta x, \zeta^{-1} y): the stack [A2/ΞΌn][\mathbb{A}^2/\mu_n] is smooth, but the coarse space is the Anβˆ’1A_{n-1} singularity Spec⁑k[u,v,w]/(uvβˆ’wn)\operatorname{Spec} k[u,v,w]/(uv - w^n).

This illustrates a key principle: stacky smoothness is weaker than scheme smoothness. The stack remembers the smooth local structure (it is locally the quotient of a smooth space), while the coarse space has a singularity at the fixed point.

ExampleCoarse space of weighted projective stack

The weighted projective stack P(a0,…,an)\mathcal{P}(a_0, \ldots, a_n) has coarse moduli space P(a0,…,an)\mathbb{P}(a_0, \ldots, a_n), the classical weighted projective variety. When the weights are not all equal, P(a0,…,an)\mathbb{P}(a_0, \ldots, a_n) has cyclic quotient singularities at the coordinate vertices.

For P(1,1,2)\mathcal{P}(1, 1, 2): the coarse space P(1,1,2)\mathbb{P}(1,1,2) is isomorphic to the quadric cone V(xyβˆ’z2)βŠ‚P3V(xy - z^2) \subset \mathbb{P}^3 (it has an A1A_1 singularity at the vertex [0:0:1][0:0:1]). The stack P(1,1,2)\mathcal{P}(1,1,2) is smooth.

ExampleCoarse moduli of abelian varieties

The stack Ag\mathcal{A}_g of principally polarized abelian varieties has coarse moduli space AgA_g. Over C\mathbb{C}, Ag=Sp(2g,Z)\HgA_g = \mathrm{Sp}(2g, \mathbb{Z}) \backslash \mathfrak{H}_g (the Siegel modular variety).

For g=1g = 1: A1=Aj1A_1 = \mathbb{A}^1_j (the jj-line), since principally polarized abelian varieties of dimension 1 are elliptic curves.

For g=2g = 2: A2A_2 is a 3-dimensional variety. The Torelli map M2β†’A2M_2 \to A_2 is an isomorphism onto its image (since every principally polarized abelian surface that is a Jacobian is the Jacobian of a unique curve of genus 2).

For g=3g = 3: A3A_3 has dimension 6, and the Torelli map M3β†’A3M_3 \to A_3 is generically injective (but not surjective: the image has codimension 0 since dim⁑M3=6=dim⁑A3\dim M_3 = 6 = \dim A_3, but not all ppav of dimension 3 are Jacobians -- this is the Schottky problem).

ExampleCoarse space of a root stack

The root stack D/Xr\sqrt[r]{D/X} (for a smooth divisor DβŠ‚XD \subset X) has coarse moduli space XX itself. The map Ο€:D/Xrβ†’X\pi : \sqrt[r]{D/X} \to X is an isomorphism over Xβˆ–DX \setminus D and is a ΞΌr\mu_r-gerbe along DD.

For the pushforward: if F\mathcal{F} is a coherent sheaf on D/Xr\sqrt[r]{D/X}, then Ο€βˆ—F\pi_*\mathcal{F} is a coherent sheaf on XX with a filtration determined by the ΞΌr\mu_r-action on the fibers over DD. This connects to the theory of parabolic sheaves.

ExampleModuli of Higgs bundles -- coarse space

The moduli stack of semistable Higgs bundles Higgsnss(C)\mathcal{H}iggs_n^{\mathrm{ss}}(C) has a coarse moduli space MH\mathcal{M}_H (the Hitchin moduli space), which is a quasi-projective variety. For n=2n = 2 on a genus-gg curve: dim⁑MH=2(4(gβˆ’1))=8gβˆ’8(asΒ realΒ manifold:Β dim⁑R=16gβˆ’16).\dim \mathcal{M}_H = 2(4(g-1)) = 8g - 8 \quad (\text{as real manifold: } \dim_{\mathbb{R}} = 16g - 16). Actually for rank nn and genus gg: dim⁑MH=2n2(gβˆ’1)\dim \mathcal{M}_H = 2n^2(g-1).

The Hitchin map h:MH→Bh : \mathcal{M}_H \to \mathcal{B} (to the Hitchin base) makes MH\mathcal{M}_H into a completely integrable system. The generic fiber is an abelian variety (the Prym of the spectral curve).

ExampleCoarse space of a gerbe

Let X→X\mathcal{X} \to X be a μn\mu_n-gerbe over a scheme XX. Then the coarse moduli space of X\mathcal{X} is XX itself. The coarse map π:X→X\pi : \mathcal{X} \to X forgets the gerbe structure entirely.

For the pushforward of sheaves: Ο€βˆ—OX=OX\pi_*\mathcal{O}_\mathcal{X} = \mathcal{O}_X, but for a line bundle L\mathcal{L} of weight jj (under the ΞΌn\mu_n-action) on X\mathcal{X}, Ο€βˆ—L=0\pi_*\mathcal{L} = 0 if j≑̸0(modn)j \not\equiv 0 \pmod{n}. This is because the ΞΌn\mu_n-invariant part of a weight-jj representation is zero for jβ‰ 0j \neq 0.

ExampleQuotient of torus by involution

Let EE be an elliptic curve with involution ΞΉ:zβ†¦βˆ’z\iota : z \mapsto -z. The stack [E/⟨ι⟩][E/\langle\iota\rangle] is a smooth DM stack. The coarse moduli space is E/βŸ¨ΞΉβŸ©β‰…P1E/\langle\iota\rangle \cong \mathbb{P}^1 (the Weierstrass model). The four fixed points of ΞΉ\iota (the 2-torsion points) become orbifold points of order 2 in the stack, and ordinary double points are not introduced in P1\mathbb{P}^1 (which is already smooth), but the map [E/⟨ι⟩]β†’P1[E/\langle\iota\rangle] \to \mathbb{P}^1 has nontrivial ΞΌ2\mu_2-stabilizers at 4 points.

The pushforward Ο€βˆ—O[E/⟨ι⟩]=OP1\pi_*\mathcal{O}_{[E/\langle\iota\rangle]} = \mathcal{O}_{\mathbb{P}^1}, consistent with H0(E,OE)⟨ι⟩=kH^0(E, \mathcal{O}_E)^{\langle\iota\rangle} = k.

ExampleCoarse space of Kontsevich stack

The Kontsevich stack Mβ€Ύ0,n(Pr,d)\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{0,n}(\mathbb{P}^r, d) of degree-dd rational stable maps to Pr\mathbb{P}^r is a proper DM stack. Its coarse moduli space Mβ€Ύ0,n(Pr,d)\overline{M}_{0,n}(\mathbb{P}^r, d) is a projective variety. For r=2r = 2 and d=1d = 1: Mβ€Ύ0,0(P2,1)β‰…(P2)βˆ—\overline{M}_{0,0}(\mathbb{P}^2, 1) \cong (\mathbb{P}^2)^* (the dual projective plane, parametrizing lines in P2\mathbb{P}^2).

The virtual fundamental class lives on the stack Mβ€Ύ0,n(Pr,d)\overline{\mathcal{M}}_{0,n}(\mathbb{P}^r, d), but Gromov--Witten invariants (intersection numbers) can be computed on the coarse space since the pushforward Ο€βˆ—\pi_* preserves degree for proper maps (at least in characteristic zero, where the orders of stabilizers are invertible).

ExampleWhen coarse moduli fails to be a scheme

The coarse moduli space is always an algebraic space but may not be a scheme. An example: let X\mathcal{X} be a smooth DM stack whose coarse space MM is an algebraic space that is not a scheme (such examples exist in dimension β‰₯3\geq 3, cf. Hironaka's example).

More commonly: MgM_g is a scheme for gβ‰₯2g \geq 2 (in fact quasi-projective), Mβ€Ύg\overline{M}_g is projective, AgA_g is quasi-projective. For these classical moduli problems, the coarse spaces are always schemes.


Coarse moduli and sheaf theory

RemarkPushforward and invariants

For a DM stack X\mathcal{X} with coarse moduli space π:X→M\pi : \mathcal{X} \to M:

  • In characteristic zero (or when the orders of all stabilizer groups are invertible in the base): Ο€βˆ—\pi_* is exact on coherent sheaves and Ο€βˆ—OX=OM\pi_*\mathcal{O}_\mathcal{X} = \mathcal{O}_M.

  • In positive characteristic (when orders of stabilizers are divisible by the characteristic): Ο€βˆ—\pi_* may not be exact, and higher direct images RiΟ€βˆ—R^i\pi_* may be nonzero. This leads to subtle pathologies.

The Chevalley--Shephard--Todd theorem in the affine case: if GβŠ‚GL(V)G \subset \mathrm{GL}(V) is a finite group generated by pseudo-reflections and ∣G∣|G| is invertible in kk, then V/GV/G is smooth (k[V]Gk[V]^G is a polynomial ring). In the stack setting: [V/G]β†’V/G[V/G] \to V/G is the coarse map, and the smoothness of V/GV/G is a "coincidence" -- the stack [V/G][V/G] is always smooth.


Summary

The coarse moduli space MM of a stack X\mathcal{X} is the universal algebraic space receiving a map from X\mathcal{X}, with a bijection on geometric points. It exists for stacks with finite inertia (by Keel--Mori) and provides the bridge to classical algebraic geometry. However, the coarse space loses automorphism information and may acquire singularities, making the stack itself the more natural object for many purposes.