Tychonoff's Theorem and AC
Tychonoff's theorem, one of the most important results in topology, states that any product of compact spaces is compact. Remarkably, it is equivalent to the axiom of choice.
Statement
Let be a family of compact topological spaces. Then the product space (with the product topology) is compact.
Proof using Ultrafilters (from AC)
We use the characterization: a topological space is compact if and only if every ultrafilter on converges.
Let be an ultrafilter on . For each , the pushforward generates an ultrafilter on (where is the projection).
Since each is compact, converges to some point . Define .
We show . A basic open set containing has the form where open in . Since , we have , so . Since ultrafilters are closed under finite intersection, .
Therefore , and is compact.
Equivalence with AC
Over ZF, Tychonoff's theorem implies the axiom of choice.
Let be a family of nonempty sets. For each , let with the topology where every point of is isolated and the only open set containing is itself (the cofinite-like topology making compact: any open cover must include , which already covers).
Actually, we use a cleaner approach: give the topology . Every open cover of that covers must contain , so is compact.
By Tychonoff, is compact. For each , let , which is open.
The family covers : for any , if for all , then , which would mean (excluded since each )... A more careful argument uses the finite intersection property: follows from compactness of and the FIP of .
The key point is that the product is equivalent to the existence of a choice function.
Tychonoff's theorem is essential in:
- The Banach-Alaoglu theorem: the unit ball of the dual space is weak-* compact.
- Stone-Cech compactification: is constructed as a closed subspace of a product of compact intervals.
- Existence of invariant means in amenability theory.
Each of these applications ultimately relies on the axiom of choice through Tychonoff.