ConceptComplete

Spectrum (Stable Homotopy Theory)

A spectrum is the fundamental object of stable homotopy theory. Classically, a spectrum is a sequence of pointed spaces EnE_n with structure maps Ξ£Enβ†’En+1\Sigma E_n \to E_{n+1}. In the ∞\infty-categorical framework, spectra form the initial stable presentable ∞\infty-category: the universal home for homological algebra. Spectra represent generalized cohomology theories and provide the natural coefficient system for stable phenomena.


Definition

Definition5.1Spectrum (infinity-categorical)

The ∞\infty-category of spectra Sp⁑\operatorname{Sp} is defined as the stabilization of the ∞\infty-category of pointed spaces:

Sp⁑=Sp⁑(Sβˆ—)=lim⁑(β‹―β†’Ξ©Sβˆ—β†’Ξ©Sβˆ—β†’Ξ©Sβˆ—)\operatorname{Sp} = \operatorname{Sp}(\mathcal{S}_*) = \lim\left(\cdots \xrightarrow{\Omega} \mathcal{S}_* \xrightarrow{\Omega} \mathcal{S}_* \xrightarrow{\Omega} \mathcal{S}_*\right)

A spectrum EE is a sequence of pointed spaces (E0,E1,E2,…)(E_0, E_1, E_2, \ldots) with equivalences En≃ΩEn+1E_n \simeq \Omega E_{n+1} for all nn. The ∞\infty-category Sp⁑\operatorname{Sp} is stable and presentable.

Definition5.2Homotopy groups of a spectrum

For a spectrum EE, the nn-th homotopy group is:

Ο€n(E)=colim⁑kΟ€n+k(Ek)β‰…Ο€0(Ξ©nE0)Β forΒ nβ‰₯0\pi_n(E) = \operatorname{colim}_k \pi_{n+k}(E_k) \cong \pi_0(\Omega^n E_0) \text{ for } n \geq 0

and Ο€n(E)=Ο€0(Eβˆ’n)\pi_n(E) = \pi_0(E_{-n}) for n<0n < 0. Note that Ο€n(E)\pi_n(E) is defined for all n∈Zn \in \mathbb{Z}, including negative values. This is the hallmark of stable homotopy theory.


Key Examples

ExampleThe sphere spectrum

The sphere spectrum S\mathbb{S} has Sn=Sn\mathbb{S}_n = S^n with the standard structure maps ΣSn→Sn+1\Sigma S^n \to S^{n+1} (identity maps). Its homotopy groups are the stable homotopy groups of spheres:

Ο€n(S)=Ο€ns=colim⁑kΟ€n+k(Sk)\pi_n(\mathbb{S}) = \pi_n^s = \operatorname{colim}_k \pi_{n+k}(S^k)

For example: Ο€0(S)=Z\pi_0(\mathbb{S}) = \mathbb{Z}, Ο€1(S)=Z/2\pi_1(\mathbb{S}) = \mathbb{Z}/2, Ο€2(S)=Z/2\pi_2(\mathbb{S}) = \mathbb{Z}/2, Ο€3(S)=Z/24\pi_3(\mathbb{S}) = \mathbb{Z}/24.

The sphere spectrum is the unit for the smash product monoidal structure on Sp⁑\operatorname{Sp}.

ExampleEilenberg--MacLane spectra

For an abelian group AA, the Eilenberg--MacLane spectrum HAHA has (HA)n=K(A,n)(HA)_n = K(A, n). Its homotopy groups are:

πn(HA)={An=00n≠0\pi_n(HA) = \begin{cases} A & n = 0 \\ 0 & n \neq 0 \end{cases}

HAHA represents ordinary cohomology: Hn(X;A)β‰…[X,Ξ£nHA]=[Σ∞X,Ξ£nHA]H^n(X; A) \cong [X, \Sigma^n HA] = [\Sigma^\infty X, \Sigma^n HA].

For a ring RR, HRHR is a ring spectrum and Mod⁑HR≃D(R)\operatorname{Mod}_{HR} \simeq D(R) (the derived ∞\infty-category).

ExampleSuspension spectra

For a pointed space XX, the suspension spectrum Σ∞X\Sigma^\infty X has (Σ∞X)n=Ξ£nX(\Sigma^\infty X)_n = \Sigma^n X. This gives the left adjoint Σ∞⊣Ω∞:Sβˆ—β‡„Sp⁑\Sigma^\infty \dashv \Omega^\infty: \mathcal{S}_* \rightleftarrows \operatorname{Sp}.

Σ∞S0=S\Sigma^\infty S^0 = \mathbb{S} is the sphere spectrum. The stable homotopy groups Ο€ns(X)=Ο€n(Σ∞X)\pi_n^s(X) = \pi_n(\Sigma^\infty X) are the "stable limit" of Ο€n+k(Ξ£kX)\pi_{n+k}(\Sigma^k X).

ExampleTopological K-theory spectra

The complex K-theory spectrum KUKU has KU2n=ZΓ—BUKU_{2n} = \mathbb{Z} \times BU and KU2n+1=UKU_{2n+1} = U (Bott periodicity: Ξ©2(BUΓ—Z)≃BUΓ—Z\Omega^2 (BU \times \mathbb{Z}) \simeq BU \times \mathbb{Z}). Its homotopy groups are 22-periodic:

Ο€n(KU)={ZnΒ even0nΒ odd\pi_n(KU) = \begin{cases} \mathbb{Z} & n \text{ even} \\ 0 & n \text{ odd} \end{cases}

KUKU represents complex topological K-theory: KU0(X)=K0(X)KU^0(X) = K^0(X), the Grothendieck group of complex vector bundles on XX.

Similarly, KOKO represents real K-theory with 88-periodic homotopy groups.

ExampleComplex cobordism spectrum

The complex cobordism spectrum MUMU has (MU)n=Thom⁑(BU(n),Ξ³n)(MU)_n = \operatorname{Thom}(BU(n), \gamma_n) (the Thom space of the universal bundle). Its homotopy ring Ο€βˆ—(MU)\pi_*(MU) is a polynomial ring:

Ο€βˆ—(MU)β‰…Z[x1,x2,x3,…],∣xi∣=2i\pi_*(MU) \cong \mathbb{Z}[x_1, x_2, x_3, \ldots], \quad |x_i| = 2i

MUMU is central to chromatic homotopy theory: the formal group law associated to MUMU classifies all complex-oriented cohomology theories.


The Smash Product

ExampleSymmetric monoidal structure

The ∞\infty-category Sp⁑\operatorname{Sp} has a symmetric monoidal structure given by the smash product ∧\wedge (or βŠ—\otimes). The unit is the sphere spectrum S\mathbb{S}.

Key properties:

  • HA∧HB≃H(AβŠ—ZB)HA \wedge HB \simeq H(A \otimes_{\mathbb{Z}} B) for abelian groups.
  • Σ∞X∧Σ∞Yβ‰ƒΞ£βˆž(X∧Y)\Sigma^\infty X \wedge \Sigma^\infty Y \simeq \Sigma^\infty(X \wedge Y) for pointed spaces.
  • S∧E≃E\mathbb{S} \wedge E \simeq E for any spectrum.

Ring spectra (also called E1E_1-rings or A∞A_\infty-rings) are monoid objects in (Sp⁑,∧)(\operatorname{Sp}, \wedge). Commutative ring spectra (E∞E_\infty-rings) are commutative monoids.

ExampleModule spectra

For a ring spectrum RR, the ∞\infty-category Mod⁑R\operatorname{Mod}_R of (left) RR-module spectra is a stable presentable ∞\infty-category. When R=HZR = H\mathbb{Z}:

Mod⁑HZ≃D(Z)\operatorname{Mod}_{H\mathbb{Z}} \simeq D(\mathbb{Z})

The derived tensor product and derived Hom of chain complexes correspond to the smash product and function spectrum of HZH\mathbb{Z}-modules.

More generally, for any ordinary ring AA, Mod⁑HA≃D(A)\operatorname{Mod}_{HA} \simeq D(A).


Connective and Nonconnective Spectra

Definition5.3Connective spectrum

A spectrum EE is connective if Ο€n(E)=0\pi_n(E) = 0 for n<0n < 0. The full subcategory of connective spectra Sp⁑β‰₯0βŠ‚Sp⁑\operatorname{Sp}_{\geq 0} \subset \operatorname{Sp} is a presentable ∞\infty-category but is NOT stable (the suspension of a connective spectrum is connective, but the loop of a connective spectrum may not be).

There is an adjunction Ο„β‰₯0⊣i:Sp⁑β‰₯0⇄Sp⁑\tau_{\geq 0} \dashv i: \operatorname{Sp}_{\geq 0} \rightleftarrows \operatorname{Sp} where Ο„β‰₯0\tau_{\geq 0} truncates to the connective cover.

ExampleConnective vs. nonconnective
  • HZH\mathbb{Z} is connective (Ο€n=0\pi_n = 0 for nβ‰ 0n \neq 0).
  • S\mathbb{S} is connective (Ο€ns=0\pi_n^s = 0 for n<0n < 0).
  • KUKU is NOT connective (Ο€βˆ’2(KU)=Z\pi_{-2}(KU) = \mathbb{Z}).
  • The Eilenberg--MacLane spectrum Ξ£βˆ’nHA\Sigma^{-n} HA (for n>0n > 0) is not connective.

Connective spectra are equivalent to grouplike E∞E_\infty-spaces (infinite loop spaces), via Ω∞\Omega^\infty.


Relation to Spaces

ExampleInfinite loop spaces

The functor Ω∞:Sp⁑→Sβˆ—\Omega^\infty: \operatorname{Sp} \to \mathcal{S}_* sends a spectrum EE to its underlying infinite loop space Ω∞E=E0\Omega^\infty E = E_0. The left adjoint Σ∞:Sβˆ—β†’Sp⁑\Sigma^\infty: \mathcal{S}_* \to \operatorname{Sp} is the suspension spectrum.

Ω∞\Omega^\infty does NOT preserve the stable structure: it only sees the "connective part" of a spectrum. But it is an equivalence on connective spectra (up to group completion): Sp⁑β‰₯0≃Mon⁑E∞gp(S)\operatorname{Sp}_{\geq 0} \simeq \operatorname{Mon}_{E_\infty}^{\mathrm{gp}}(\mathcal{S}) (grouplike E∞E_\infty-spaces).

ExampleThom spectra

Given a map f:X→BGL1(S)f: X \to BGL_1(\mathbb{S}) (the classifying space for stable spherical fibrations), the Thom spectrum Mf=XfMf = X^f is the colimit of the induced diagram of suspension spectra. Important examples:

  • MOMO, MSOMSO, MUMU, MSpMSp: cobordism spectra classifying manifolds.
  • The Thom isomorphism: Hβˆ—(Mf)β‰…Hβˆ—βˆ’n(X)H_*(Mf) \cong H_{*-n}(X) (when ff is orientable of rank nn).

Summary

RemarkKey points

Spectra are the objects of stable homotopy theory:

  1. A spectrum is a sequence of pointed spaces with En≃ΩEn+1E_n \simeq \Omega E_{n+1}; homotopy groups Ο€n(E)\pi_n(E) exist for all n∈Zn \in \mathbb{Z}.

  2. Sp⁑\operatorname{Sp} is the initial stable presentable ∞\infty-category (the stabilization of Sβˆ—\mathcal{S}_*).

  3. The smash product gives Sp⁑\operatorname{Sp} a symmetric monoidal structure; ring spectra and their modules generalize rings and modules.

  4. Mod⁑HA≃D(A)\operatorname{Mod}_{HA} \simeq D(A): module spectra over Eilenberg--MacLane spectra recover derived categories.

  5. Key examples: sphere spectrum S\mathbb{S}, Eilenberg--MacLane HAHA, K-theory KUKU, cobordism MUMU.