Quillen Adjunction and Equivalence
Quillen adjunctions and equivalences are the correct notions of morphism and equivalence between model categories. A Quillen adjunction is an adjunction that respects the model structures, and a Quillen equivalence is one that induces an equivalence of homotopy categories. These concepts provide the framework for comparing different models of the same homotopy theory.
Quillen Adjunctions
Let and be model categories. A Quillen adjunction is an adjunction
(with left adjoint to ) satisfying any of the following equivalent conditions:
- preserves cofibrations and trivial cofibrations.
- preserves fibrations and trivial fibrations.
- preserves cofibrations and preserves fibrations.
- preserves trivial cofibrations and preserves trivial fibrations.
We call the left Quillen functor and the right Quillen functor.
The geometric realization--singular set adjunction is a Quillen adjunction. The left adjoint preserves cofibrations (monomorphisms become relative CW inclusions) and trivial cofibrations (anodyne extensions become trivial cofibrations in ).
The Dold--Kan correspondence gives a Quillen adjunction
where is the normalized chain complex functor and is its right adjoint. This is in fact a Quillen equivalence: simplicial abelian groups and non-negatively graded chain complexes have equivalent homotopy theories.
The free-forgetful adjunction (where is the constant simplicial set and evaluates at level ) is a Quillen adjunction from the trivial model structure on to the Kan--Quillen model structure on .
For a ring homomorphism , the extension-restriction of scalars adjunction
is a Quillen adjunction (with appropriate model structures). The derived functors give (derived tensor product along ).
Derived Adjunctions
A Quillen adjunction induces a total derived adjunction on homotopy categories:
where (apply to a cofibrant replacement) and (apply to a fibrant replacement).
These are adjoint: .
The tensor-hom adjunction for -modules gives a derived adjunction:
on derived categories. This is the fundamental adjunction of homological algebra: and are the derived functors of this adjunction.
For a morphism of schemes, the direct-inverse image adjunction on sheaf categories gives a derived adjunction:
on derived categories of sheaves. Here computes higher direct images , and is the derived pullback.
Quillen Equivalences
A Quillen adjunction is a Quillen equivalence if the derived adjunction is an equivalence of homotopy categories:
Equivalent conditions: for every cofibrant and fibrant , a map is a weak equivalence in if and only if the adjunct is a weak equivalence in .
The adjunction is a Quillen equivalence. The unit is a weak equivalence for Kan complexes, and the counit is a weak equivalence for all spaces. Thus .
The Dold--Kan adjunction is a Quillen equivalence. The homotopy category of simplicial abelian groups is equivalent to the derived category of non-negatively graded abelian groups.
The identity functor is NOT a Quillen equivalence (and not even a Quillen adjunction in general). The Joyal model structure has more weak equivalences (categorical equivalences) than the Kan--Quillen model structure, so they capture different homotopy theories. The Joyal model structure models -categories, while Kan--Quillen models -groupoids (spaces).
There is a Quillen equivalence between the Joyal model structure on (modeling quasi-categories) and the model structure on Segal categories (bisimplicial sets satisfying the homotopy Segal condition). This shows that quasi-categories and Segal categories provide equivalent models for -categories.
Properties of Quillen Equivalences
If and are Quillen equivalences, then is a Quillen equivalence. This allows "chaining" Quillen equivalences to compare distant model categories.
For instance, the chain and (forgetful) allow comparison of chain complexes with simplicial sets.
Two model categories and are Quillen equivalent if they are connected by a zigzag of Quillen equivalences:
This happens when there is no single Quillen equivalence between them but they still have equivalent homotopy theories. The notion of Quillen equivalent model categories is an equivalence relation on model categories.
Detecting Quillen Equivalences
A Quillen adjunction is a Quillen equivalence if and only if:
-
reflects weak equivalences between fibrant objects: if is fibrant in and is a weak equivalence in , then is a weak equivalence in .
-
For every cofibrant , the map (unit followed by fibrant replacement) is a weak equivalence.
Alternatively: is a Quillen equivalence iff is essentially surjective on and for cofibrant , the derived unit is a weak equivalence.
Summary
Quillen adjunctions and equivalences compare model categories:
-
A Quillen adjunction preserves the model structure: preserves cofibrations and trivial cofibrations; preserves fibrations and trivial fibrations.
-
Every Quillen adjunction induces a derived adjunction on homotopy categories.
-
A Quillen equivalence induces an equivalence of homotopy categories, meaning the two model categories encode the "same" homotopy theory.
-
Key examples: (spaces), (Dold--Kan), and various models of -categories are Quillen equivalent.
-
Quillen equivalences upgrade to equivalences of -categories, providing a more refined comparison than the homotopy category alone.