Homotopy Category Ho(M)
The homotopy category of a model category is obtained by formally inverting all weak equivalences. It is the "shadow" of the full homotopy theory that can be captured by an ordinary category. While loses higher homotopical information (composition of homotopy classes, mapping spaces), it is computable and captures essential invariants like homotopy groups and homology.
Construction
The homotopy category of a model category is the localization : the category obtained by formally inverting all weak equivalences.
Concretely, has the same objects as , and morphisms from to are equivalence classes of zigzags where backward arrows are weak equivalences.
The model structure provides a much more tractable description: for bifibrant objects and ,
where the homotopy relation uses cylinder or path objects.
Let be two morphisms in .
A left homotopy from to is a map (where is a cylinder object for ) such that and .
A right homotopy from to is a map (where is a path object for ) such that and .
When is cofibrant and is fibrant, left and right homotopy coincide and define an equivalence relation. The set of equivalence classes is denoted .
Examples
has objects all topological spaces and morphisms are homotopy classes of maps between CW replacements:
where is a CW approximation of . For CW complexes and , this is simply , the set of homotopy classes of continuous maps.
Since all spaces are fibrant in , we only need cofibrant replacement.
has morphisms computed as where is a fibrant replacement (Kan complex approximation) of . Since all simplicial sets are cofibrant, we only need fibrant replacement.
For Kan complexes and : , the connected components of the mapping space (simplicial function complex).
is the derived category . Morphisms are computed via projective or injective resolutions:
where is a projective resolution and is an injective resolution.
This recovers the classical derived category construction via chain homotopy classes of maps between resolutions.
For a pointed model category (with a zero object), is a pointed category with suspension and loop functors:
These satisfy (the loop-suspension adjunction in the homotopy category).
Total Derived Functors
Let be a functor between model categories. The total left derived functor is defined by
where is a cofibrant replacement of . The total right derived functor is where is a fibrant replacement.
These are well-defined when preserves weak equivalences between cofibrant (resp. fibrant) objects.
For a ring , the tensor product does not preserve quasi-isomorphisms in general. Its left derived functor is:
where is a projective resolution. The homology recovers the classical Tor functors.
The internal Hom has right derived functor:
where is an injective resolution. Its cohomology recovers the classical Ext functors.
For a scheme and a sheaf , the global sections functor has right derived functor , computed via injective resolution. The cohomology is sheaf cohomology.
Limitations of the Homotopy Category
The homotopy category loses crucial higher homotopical information:
-
Mapping spaces: only records of the mapping spaces, not the full mapping space. The composition forgets the homotopy-coherent composition.
-
Homotopy limits/colimits: The homotopy category does not have good limits and colimits. Homotopy pullbacks in do not satisfy the universal property of pullbacks.
-
Obstruction theory: Higher obstructions to lifting/extending maps require mapping space data, not just homotopy classes.
This is the fundamental motivation for -categories: they capture the full mapping spaces, not just .
The homotopy category of pointed spaces is not abelian and not even additive in general. However, for stable homotopy theory ( for spectra), the homotopy category is triangulated. This triangulated structure is a remnant of the richer stable -categorical structure.
Consider and in . The set (classified by degree). But the full mapping space has infinitely many connected components (one for each degree), and the component of degree- maps has nontrivial homotopy groups related to the homotopy groups of .
The homotopy category sees only , losing all this higher information. An -category retains the full mapping space.
The Localization Functor
The localization functor is the identity on objects and sends each morphism to its homotopy class (after fibrant-cofibrant replacement). It is universal among functors inverting weak equivalences:
For any functor sending weak equivalences to isomorphisms, there exists a unique functor with .
This universal property justifies the homotopy category as the "best ordinary category approximation" to the homotopy theory of .
Summary
The homotopy category captures the essence of homotopy theory at the cost of higher information:
-
is obtained by inverting weak equivalences.
-
Between bifibrant objects, morphisms in are homotopy classes .
-
Derived functors live on the homotopy category, computed via cofibrant/fibrant replacement.
-
The homotopy category loses mapping space information, homotopy limits/colimits, and higher coherences.
-
This limitation motivates -categories, which capture the full homotopy-coherent structure that can only partially represent.