Deligne-Mumford Theorem on
The theorem of Deligne and Mumford (1969) is one of the foundational results in the theory of algebraic stacks. It establishes that the moduli of stable curves forms a proper smooth Deligne-Mumford stack, providing both the first major example of a DM stack and the compactification of the moduli of smooth curves.
1. Statement of the Theorem
For , the moduli stack of stable curves of genus satisfies:
- is a smooth algebraic stack of dimension over .
- is proper (satisfies the valuative criterion for properness).
- is a Deligne-Mumford stack (the diagonal is unramified; equivalently, automorphism groups are finite and reduced in characteristic 0).
- is irreducible over every algebraically closed field.
- The open substack parametrizing smooth curves is dense.
2. Finiteness of Automorphisms
The DM property rests on the finiteness of automorphism groups of stable curves.
Let be a stable curve of genus over an algebraically closed field . Then the automorphism group is finite. Moreover:
- If is smooth, (Hurwitz bound).
- In general, is bounded by a function of alone.
The Hurwitz bound for smooth curves of genus follows from the Riemann-Hurwitz formula applied to . The bound is achieved by the Klein quartic for : which has , with .
Every genus 2 curve is hyperelliptic with involution . The full automorphism group satisfies:
- Generic curve: .
- : , order 12.
- : has order 10.
- : , order 10.
- : has order (the maximum for genus 2).
Consider the stable curve obtained by taking an elliptic curve and identifying two points . Then includes automorphisms of fixing as a set. If is generic and are generic, then (or from the involution swapping and when such exists). The group is always finite.
3. Smoothness
The stack is smooth over . At a point corresponding to a stable curve with nodes:
- The tangent space has dimension .
- The local deformation space is smooth: .
- The first parameters correspond to smoothing the nodes, and correspond to deformations preserving the nodes.
Let be a stable curve of genus with a single node . Locally at , . The universal deformation of the node is , and the remaining deformations give a smooth base .
The boundary divisor is locally cut out by , so is a smooth divisor in the smooth stack .
A maximally degenerate stable curve of genus has nodes (the maximum for a stable curve). Every component is rational () with exactly 3 special points (nodes). The dual graph is a trivalent graph with vertices, edges, and first Betti number .
At such a point, the deformation space is where each smooths one node. The boundary of has normal crossings at this point, cut out by .
4. Properness via Stable Reduction
Let be a DVR with fraction field and algebraically closed residue field , and let be a smooth curve of genus over . Then after a finite extension , the curve extends to a stable curve over the integral closure of in .
This theorem is precisely the valuative criterion of properness for : given a map (a curve over ), after a base change, it extends to a map (a stable curve over ).
Consider the family of elliptic curves over . At , the curve has a node at . The stable reduction gives a rational curve with a node (the Neron model's special fiber has a node).
For pointed curves (), the stable limit is uniquely determined. For (where two branch points collide), the stable limit in is the rational curve with and identified.
Consider the family of genus 2 curves over . At , the fiber has a non-stable singularity (a cusp of sorts). After the base change , we get , which can be resolved to a stable curve. The stable limit is a curve with two rational components meeting at three points.
5. Irreducibility
The stack (and hence ) is irreducible over every algebraically closed field. Over , every geometric fiber of is irreducible.
The irreducibility in characteristic 0 follows from the Teichmuller theory: the Teichmuller space (the universal cover of the moduli space) is homeomorphic to , hence connected.
In positive characteristic, Deligne and Mumford prove irreducibility by showing that every stable curve over can be lifted to characteristic 0 (using the smoothness of over ) and then specializing from the characteristic-0 irreducibility. Specifically, since is smooth over and its generic fiber (over ) is irreducible, every special fiber (over ) must also be irreducible.
For , is a point (just ), trivially irreducible. For , is irreducible (the -line). The first nontrivial case is , where is a 3-dimensional irreducible variety.
6. The Coarse Moduli Space
The coarse moduli space associated to is a projective variety of dimension over . The morphism is proper, quasi-finite, and an isomorphism over the locus of curves with trivial automorphism group.
- : is a 3-dimensional projective variety. Every genus 2 curve has , so the coarse moduli has quotient singularities everywhere.
- : is a 6-dimensional projective variety. The non-hyperelliptic curves form an open dense subset. A generic genus 3 curve has , so is generically smooth.
- : The generic curve has trivial automorphism group, so is generically a manifold.
Harris-Mumford (1982) and Eisenbud-Harris (1987) proved:
- For , is of general type (i.e., ).
- For , is unirational (rational or close to rational).
- The cases remain largely open (Kodaira dimension unknown for most of these).
The key technique is computing the canonical class in terms of the tautological classes and : and showing it is ample (big) for .
7. Consequences and Applications
For , the Picard group of is: where is the first Chern class of the Hodge bundle. For the compactification: where are the boundary divisor classes.
On , key intersection numbers include:
- on (since is not ample on the boundary).
- (as a rational number, reflecting the stacky structure).
- .
Stable curves have finite automorphism groups. If we allowed semistable curves (nodal curves where rational components meet the rest in points instead of ), automorphism groups could be infinite (e.g., a rational bridge with 2 nodes has automorphisms). This is why the stability condition is essential for the DM property.