ProofComplete

Proof of K-Groups of Finite Fields

Quillen's computation of the K-groups of finite fields was one of the first triumphs of higher algebraic K-theory. The result connects algebraic K-theory to topological K-theory via the Adams operations and the Brauer lift.


Statement

Theorem2.3K-groups of finite fields (Quillen)

For a finite field Fq\mathbb{F}_q with q=pfq = p^f elements:

Kn(Fq)={Zn=0Z/(qiβˆ’1)Zn=2iβˆ’1,β€…β€Šiβ‰₯10nβ‰₯2,β€…β€ŠnΒ evenK_n(\mathbb{F}_q) = \begin{cases} \mathbb{Z} & n = 0 \\ \mathbb{Z}/(q^i - 1)\mathbb{Z} & n = 2i - 1, \; i \geq 1 \\ 0 & n \geq 2, \; n \text{ even} \end{cases}


The Brauer lift

Definition2.8Brauer lift

Fix an embedding ΞΉ:Fβ€ΎqΓ—β†ͺCΓ—\iota: \overline{\mathbb{F}}_q^{\times} \hookrightarrow \mathbb{C}^{\times} (choosing compatible roots of unity). The Brauer lift is the map

ρ~:GLn(Fq)β†’GLn(C)\tilde{\rho}: GL_n(\mathbb{F}_q) \to GL_n(\mathbb{C})

defined as follows: given A∈GLn(Fq)A \in GL_n(\mathbb{F}_q), let Ξ±1,…,Ξ±n∈Fβ€ΎqΓ—\alpha_1, \ldots, \alpha_n \in \overline{\mathbb{F}}_q^{\times} be its eigenvalues (in Fβ€Ύq\overline{\mathbb{F}}_q). The Brauer character is

Ο‡~(A)=ΞΉ(Ξ±1)+β‹―+ΞΉ(Ξ±n)∈C.\tilde{\chi}(A) = \iota(\alpha_1) + \cdots + \iota(\alpha_n) \in \mathbb{C}.

This is the character of a virtual complex representation ρ~\tilde{\rho} (it may not be an actual representation, but its character is a well-defined class function). At the level of classifying spaces, we get maps

BGLn(Fq)β†’BU(n)β†’BUBGL_n(\mathbb{F}_q) \to BU(n) \to BU

and in the limit:

Ο•:BGL(Fq)β†’BU.\phi: BGL(\mathbb{F}_q) \to BU.


Proof

Proof

Step 1: The key fibration. Consider the Adams operation ψq:BUβ†’BU\psi^q: BU \to BU at the level of the infinite unitary group. Define FψqF\psi^q as the homotopy fiber of ψqβˆ’1\psi^q - 1:

Fψqβ†’BUβ†’Οˆqβˆ’1BU.F\psi^q \xrightarrow{} BU \xrightarrow{\psi^q - 1} BU.

This gives a fibration sequence. The homotopy groups of BUBU are:

Ο€n(BU)={ZnΒ even0nΒ odd\pi_n(BU) = \begin{cases} \mathbb{Z} & n \text{ even} \\ 0 & n \text{ odd} \end{cases}

The map ψqβˆ’1:Ο€2i(BU)β†’Ο€2i(BU)\psi^q - 1: \pi_{2i}(BU) \to \pi_{2i}(BU) is multiplication by qiβˆ’1q^i - 1 on Z\mathbb{Z}. From the long exact sequence of the fibration:

β‹―β†’Ο€2i(BU)β†’qiβˆ’1Ο€2i(BU)β†’Ο€2iβˆ’1(Fψq)β†’Ο€2iβˆ’1(BU)=0\cdots \to \pi_{2i}(BU) \xrightarrow{q^i - 1} \pi_{2i}(BU) \to \pi_{2i-1}(F\psi^q) \to \pi_{2i-1}(BU) = 0

we get Ο€2iβˆ’1(Fψq)β‰…Z/(qiβˆ’1)Z\pi_{2i-1}(F\psi^q) \cong \mathbb{Z}/(q^i - 1)\mathbb{Z} and Ο€2i(Fψq)=0\pi_{2i}(F\psi^q) = 0 for iβ‰₯1i \geq 1, with Ο€0(Fψq)=0\pi_0(F\psi^q) = 0.

Step 2: The Brauer lift factors through FψqF\psi^q. Quillen shows that the Brauer lift Ο•:BGL(Fq)β†’BU\phi: BGL(\mathbb{F}_q) \to BU satisfies (ψqβˆ’1)βˆ˜Ο•β‰ƒβˆ—(\psi^q - 1) \circ \phi \simeq * (null-homotopic). This is because the Frobenius Frob⁑q\operatorname{Frob}_q acts on the representation ring of GLn(Fβ€Ύq)GL_n(\overline{\mathbb{F}}_q) by ψq\psi^q, and representations over Fq\mathbb{F}_q are exactly the Frobenius-fixed points, giving ψq(ρ~)=ρ~\psi^q(\tilde{\rho}) = \tilde{\rho} for representations coming from Fq\mathbb{F}_q.

Thus Ο•\phi lifts to a map

Ο•~:BGL(Fq)β†’Fψq.\tilde{\phi}: BGL(\mathbb{F}_q) \to F\psi^q.

Step 3: The map Ο•~+\tilde{\phi}^+ is a homotopy equivalence. Applying the plus construction to the source (with respect to E(Fq)E(\mathbb{F}_q)), we get

Ο•~+:BGL(Fq)+β†’Fψq.\tilde{\phi}^+: BGL(\mathbb{F}_q)^+ \to F\psi^q.

To show this is an equivalence, Quillen proves it induces an isomorphism on homology with all finite coefficients Z/mZ\mathbb{Z}/m\mathbb{Z}.

Step 3a: Cohomology of BGLn(Fq)BGL_n(\mathbb{F}_q). Using the theory of finite groups of Lie type, Quillen computes

Hβˆ—(BGL(Fq);Fβ„“)β‰…Hβˆ—(BU;Fβ„“)ψq=1H^*(BGL(\mathbb{F}_q); \mathbb{F}_\ell) \cong H^*(BU; \mathbb{F}_\ell)^{\psi^q = 1}

for primes β„“β‰ p\ell \neq p. This is the ψq\psi^q-fixed part of the polynomial ring Fβ„“[c1,c2,…]\mathbb{F}_\ell[c_1, c_2, \ldots].

Step 3b: Comparison. The cohomology of FψqF\psi^q with Fβ„“\mathbb{F}_\ell coefficients can be computed from the Serre spectral sequence of the fibration. One obtains the same answer as in Step 3a, and Ο•~+\tilde{\phi}^+ induces the identity on these cohomology rings.

Step 3c: The pp-primary part. For β„“=p\ell = p (the characteristic), one shows separately that Hβˆ—(BGL(Fq);Fp)β‰…Hβˆ—(Fψq;Fp)H^*(BGL(\mathbb{F}_q); \mathbb{F}_p) \cong H^*(F\psi^q; \mathbb{F}_p) via the Brauer lift.

Step 4: Conclusion. By the Whitehead theorem (for simple spaces), since Ο•~+\tilde{\phi}^+ induces isomorphisms on all homology groups with finite coefficients, and both spaces have finitely generated homotopy groups, Ο•~+\tilde{\phi}^+ is a homotopy equivalence:

BGL(Fq)+≃Fψq.BGL(\mathbb{F}_q)^+ \simeq F\psi^q.

Therefore Kn(Fq)=Ο€n(BGL(Fq)+)=Ο€n(Fψq)K_n(\mathbb{F}_q) = \pi_n(BGL(\mathbb{F}_q)^+) = \pi_n(F\psi^q), which gives the stated formula. β–‘\square

β– 

Consequences

ExampleExplicit values

Computing Kn(Fq)K_n(\mathbb{F}_q) for small values:

For F2\mathbb{F}_2: K1=Z/1=0K_1 = \mathbb{Z}/1 = 0, K3=Z/3K_3 = \mathbb{Z}/3, K5=Z/31K_5 = \mathbb{Z}/31, K7=Z/127K_7 = \mathbb{Z}/127.

For F3\mathbb{F}_3: K1=Z/2K_1 = \mathbb{Z}/2, K3=Z/8K_3 = \mathbb{Z}/8, K5=Z/242K_5 = \mathbb{Z}/242, K7=Z/2186K_7 = \mathbb{Z}/2186.

The orders ∣K2iβˆ’1(Fq)∣=qiβˆ’1|K_{2i-1}(\mathbb{F}_q)| = q^i - 1 grow exponentially. Note that K1(Fq)=FqΓ—β‰…Z/(qβˆ’1)K_1(\mathbb{F}_q) = \mathbb{F}_q^{\times} \cong \mathbb{Z}/(q-1) recovers the known result.

RemarkThe Quillen--Lichtenbaum conjecture at finite fields

The computation K2iβˆ’1(Fq)β‰…Z/(qiβˆ’1)K_{2i-1}(\mathbb{F}_q) \cong \mathbb{Z}/(q^i - 1) matches the etale cohomology:

Het1(Spec⁑Fq,Zβ„“(i))β‰…Zβ„“/(qiβˆ’1)Zβ„“H^1_{\text{et}}(\operatorname{Spec} \mathbb{F}_q, \mathbb{Z}_\ell(i)) \cong \mathbb{Z}_\ell / (q^i - 1)\mathbb{Z}_\ell

for primes β„“β‰ p\ell \neq p. This is the simplest instance of the Quillen--Lichtenbaum conjecture: for "nice" schemes, algebraic K-theory with finite coefficients agrees with etale K-theory in sufficiently high degrees. This was proved in general by Voevodsky, Rost, and others via the Bloch--Kato conjecture.