Ramification
Ramification is the phenomenon where a morphism of curves fails to be a local isomorphism. It measures how fibers of a map degenerate, generalizing the branching behavior of multi-valued functions in complex analysis. The concept lies at the heart of the Hurwitz formula, the classification of covers, and has deep analogues in algebraic number theory.
Morphisms of curves and degree
Let and be smooth projective curves over an algebraically closed field , and let be a nonconstant morphism. Then is automatically finite and surjective. It induces an extension of function fields .
The degree of is the degree of the field extension:
The morphism is separable if the extension is separable, and purely inseparable if every element of is purely inseparable over . In general, where is the separable degree and is the inseparable degree.
For any point , the fiber satisfies , where is the ramification index at .
Let be a smooth plane curve of degree , and the projection from a point . A generic line through meets in points, so .
Concretely, for (a genus-1 curve of degree 3 in its Weierstrass embedding), the projection has : the generic fiber consists of the two points .
The map given by (or in affine coordinates) has degree . The function field extension is where , which has degree .
The generic fiber over consists of distinct points (the -th roots of ). Over and , the fiber has a single point with multiplicity .
Ramification index
Let be a nonconstant morphism of smooth projective curves, and a closed point with . Let be a uniformizer at (i.e., a generator of the maximal ideal ).
The ramification index of at is
where is the valuation at . Equivalently, is the largest integer such that .
- If , the morphism is unramified at .
- If , the point is a ramification point of .
- The image of a ramification point is called a branch point.
- The branch locus of is the set of all branch points in .
The fundamental relation for each :
For , (degree 2):
- Over : the fiber is , two distinct points with . Unramified.
- Over : the fiber is with . Ramified! The uniformizer at is , and where is the coordinate on the source. So .
- Over : similarly .
The branch locus is . The sum checks: (generic fiber), and (ramified fiber).
For , (degree 3):
- Over : three distinct preimages, each with .
- Over : single preimage with . Totally ramified.
- Over : single preimage with . Totally ramified.
Branch locus: . The ramification divisor is with .
The degree- Chebyshev polynomial satisfies . As a map of degree :
- Over : the preimages of are for , but some coincide. Specifically, has ramification index at each of for (the interior critical points).
- Over generic : distinct preimages.
For : branch points at . Over : preimages at with each (since and ). Over : single preimage with (since and ). So the branch locus is .
Ramification divisor and the different
Let be a separable morphism of smooth projective curves. The ramification divisor of is
This is an effective divisor supported on the ramification points of . Its degree is
In the tame case ( for all ), this coincides with the different divisor. In the wild case, the different may be strictly larger (see below).
More generally, for a finite separable morphism , the different is the effective divisor on defined by
where is computed from the local different of the extension of discrete valuation rings.
- Tame ramification (): .
- Wild ramification (): , strictly greater than .
The discriminant is the norm: , a divisor on .
Tame versus wild ramification
The distinction between tame and wild ramification is fundamental:
Tame ramification (, or with ): the local picture is , and the different exponent is . The ramification is "polynomial" and well-behaved.
Wild ramification ( with ): the different exponent satisfies , and higher ramification groups are nontrivial. The local structure is more intricate: it involves Artin-Schreier extensions in the -part.
Over , all ramification is tame. Over fields of characteristic , wild ramification arises frequently and introduces subtle phenomena.
Let have characteristic . The Artin--Schreier cover is defined by for .
This is a degree- cyclic cover (Galois group ), totally ramified above with ramification index . The different exponent at the unique point above is , which is strictly greater than when .
For , : the curve over . Here , . Wild!
For , : the curve over . Here , . The genus of is larger than it would be with tame ramification.
Ramification and differentials
For a separable morphism , the pullback of the sheaf of differentials gives a map of line bundles:
If is a local coordinate at and is a local coordinate at with , then for a unit . Differentiating:
In the tame case (), the factor is a unit, so vanishes to order exactly at . Thus:
for any nonzero rational differential on , where is the ramification divisor.
This gives the sheaf-theoretic relation: , or equivalently .
Hurwitz formula
Let be a finite separable morphism of smooth projective curves of genera and , respectively. Then
where is the ramification divisor (using instead of in the wild case).
Equivalently, taking degrees in :
Since for a curve of genus , the formula follows.
Let be a degree-2 cover with . The Hurwitz formula gives:
Each ramification point has (totally ramified), so contributes to . If there are ramification points, , and:
So must be even, and:
- : (an isomorphism after base change).
- : (elliptic curve).
- : (genus 2, all genus-2 curves are hyperelliptic).
- : (general hyperelliptic curve).
For a hyperelliptic curve where has degree with distinct roots , the map , has degree 2.
The ramification points are exactly the Weierstrass points: the points where . At each of these, the fiber is a single point with .
When instead (one root "at infinity"), the point at infinity is also a ramification point, giving total. The Hurwitz formula still gives .
For , : the 6 ramification points are for plus the point at infinity. The 6 Weierstrass points are the fixed points of the hyperelliptic involution .
Let be an isogeny of elliptic curves (both genus 1). The Hurwitz formula gives:
so , meaning is unramified everywhere. This confirms the general fact: a homomorphism of abelian varieties is etale (unramified) if and only if it is an isogeny, which is automatic for isogenies between elliptic curves in characteristic 0 (or when the degree is coprime to the characteristic).
Cyclic covers and explicit ramification
A cyclic cover of degree is given by where and ensures the cover is totally ramified above .
At each ramification point above , the ramification index is and (in the tame case, ) the contribution to is .
By Hurwitz: , giving:
For , (four branch points): .
For , : , which is not an integer! This means the ramification pattern with all and is not compatible with unless we include the point at infinity, making and .
The Fermat curve in is smooth of degree , so .
The projection , (i.e., ) has degree . Setting , we have .
The ramification occurs where is undefined, i.e., where , so , which blows up when . This happens at where (the -th roots of unity).
Over each branch point , the fiber is a single point with . There are such branch points.
Hurwitz check: gives , which is , matching the genus formula for plane curves.
Branch locus and monodromy
For a finite morphism of degree over (or more generally in the etale topology), the restriction is an unramified covering space, where is the branch locus.
The monodromy representation is the homomorphism
that records how the sheets of the cover are permuted as we loop around branch points. The image is a transitive subgroup of (since is connected), and the cover is Galois if and only if the image is a transitive subgroup acting regularly (equivalently, ).
The ramification index at a point above a branch point equals the length of the cycle in that contains the sheet corresponding to , where is a small loop around .
For a degree-2 cover branched at :
The monodromy group is . Each branch point contributes a transposition . The monodromy representation is:
The fundamental group relation requires , which holds since is even.
The cover is always Galois (since is abelian), with Galois group . The nontrivial automorphism is the hyperelliptic involution .
Consider given by (a degree-3 cyclic cover). The branch points are , and the monodromy representation maps into :
Wait -- the relation is , so . The image is , confirming the cover is Galois with group .
Hurwitz: , so . The curve is an elliptic curve.
Belyi maps
A Belyi map is a finite morphism unramified outside .
Belyi's theorem: A smooth projective curve over admits a Belyi map if and only if is defined over .
Example 1: The identity is the simplest Belyi map (degree 1, no ramification).
Example 2: is a degree-2 Belyi map. Branch points: at , so . The map is ramified at (above ) and at (above ), with at each. Unramified outside since the only critical value is (and ).
Example 3: The Belyi map gives a degree-6 cover of by (genus 0). The ramification type over is , over is , and over is . This corresponds to the dessin of a tetrahedron.
The elliptic curve has a natural degree-2 map via , branched at .
To make a Belyi map, we compose with a rational function that sends into . For instance, if , we can use , which sends .
The composition is then a degree-4 Belyi map on the curve .
Number field analogy
The analogy between function fields and number fields is one of the deepest themes in arithmetic geometry. For a number field extension (e.g., ), the ring of integers is a "curve" and primes of play the role of points of :
A prime of factors in as with where . Then:
- Split: for all , and . Analogous to an unramified point with distinct preimages.
- Inert: , , . One preimage of higher residue degree.
- Ramified: some . Exactly the branch points of the "cover."
For : a prime ramifies iff (discriminant). The branch locus is , a finite set -- just as for morphisms of curves.
The extension (i.e., ) is a "degree-2 cover" of :
- : , so . Ramified (). The prime is the unique branch point.
- : splits into two primes. Split (unramified, two preimages).
- : remains prime in . Inert (unramified, one preimage of degree 2).
This mirrors a double cover of curves: branch points (ramified primes), unramified points splitting into 2 preimages, and (unlike the geometric case) inert primes where the residue field doubles.
Ramification of specific families
Let over .
The projection is a degree-2 map to with branch points (the roots of the polynomial, all with ). By Hurwitz: .
The ramification divisor is where , with .
The canonical divisor is . Since and , , and indeed .
The Klein quartic in is a smooth plane curve of degree 4, so .
It has the remarkable automorphism group of order 168, achieving the Hurwitz bound .
The quotient map has degree 168. By Hurwitz:
The ramification has three orbits of branch points in :
- Above one branch point: 24 points with , contributing .
- Above another: 42 points with , contributing .
- Above the third: 56 points with , contributing . -- but wait, let us recheck: we need , , . Contribution to : . But we need .
The correct ramification data is: above three branch points, with orbit sizes and ramification indices :
- 24 points with : contribution .
- 84 points with : contribution .
- 56 points with : contribution .
Total: . Check: , , . Correct!
Purity and the branch locus
Let be a finite morphism of smooth curves. If is unramified at every point in for some , then is etale in a neighborhood of .
More generally (Zariski--Nagata purity): for a finite morphism of smooth varieties, the branch locus (the set of points of over which is not etale) is a pure codimension-1 subvariety. For curves, this means the branch locus is a finite set of closed points.
Riemann--Hurwitz and topology
Over , the Hurwitz formula is a consequence of the multiplicativity of the Euler characteristic for covering spaces, corrected by ramification.
For of degree , removing the branch locus and its preimage gives an honest -sheeted covering . The Euler characteristics satisfy .
Filling back in the removed points: each branch point adds to , and the points above add to . Since , we get:
Since for a compact Riemann surface, this is the Hurwitz formula.
Further examples
The curve is a degree-3 cyclic cover of via .
Branch points: and (where , a single root with ), and (where the equation becomes in suitable coordinates, again ).
So branch points, each totally ramified with . By Hurwitz:
Thus : this is an elliptic curve, not genus 2!
To get genus 2, we need more ramification: . Here the branch points are , but each root appears with exponent 1, and since each is totally ramified. The exponent sum is , so is also a branch point (since the total degree ), but there we need a separate analysis. Ultimately this gives a curve of genus (with 5 branch points).
Let be a smooth plane quartic (). Projecting from a point gives of degree 3 (a line through meets in points, one of which is , leaving others).
By Hurwitz: gives . So there are ramification points (each with , generically), corresponding to the lines through that are tangent to at some other point.
Geometrically: the number of tangent lines from to other than the tangent at itself (by the class formula for plane curves).
Summary
The essential facts about ramification for curves:
- Ramification index measures the local branching order.
- Hurwitz formula: relates genera, degree, and ramification.
- Tame vs wild: in characteristic , wild ramification () gives a larger different, requiring more care.
- Differentials detect ramification: .
- Monodromy encodes the global structure: the cover is determined (up to isomorphism) by its monodromy representation .
- Number field analogy: primes splitting, remaining inert, or ramifying in extensions mirror the behavior of fibers of morphisms of curves.