Proof: Closed Subset of a Compact Space is Compact
This fundamental result states that a closed subset of a compact space inherits compactness. Combined with the fact that compact subsets of Hausdorff spaces are closed, it gives a complete characterization of compact subsets in compact Hausdorff spaces.
Statement
Let be a compact topological space and a closed subset. Then is compact (in the subspace topology).
Proof via Open Covers
Let be an open cover of . For each , is open in the subspace topology on , so for some open set in .
Since is closed, is open in . Consider the collection:
This is an open cover of : For any , either (in which case for some , so ) or (so ).
Extract a finite subcover: Since is compact, there exist such that:
Restrict to : Intersecting both sides with :
Therefore is a finite subcover of the original cover of , and is compact.
Alternative Proof via the FIP
We use the finite intersection property characterization. Let be a collection of closed subsets of (closed in the subspace topology) with the FIP. Since is closed in , each is also closed in .
The collection (viewed as subsets of ) has the FIP: any finite intersection (this holds since FIP is the same regardless of the ambient space).
But wait: we need together with to have the FIP in . Consider the collection in . Each , so . This collection has the FIP.
Since is compact, by the FIP characterization: (the last equality since ).
So , and is compact by the FIP characterization.
Converse and Complement
If is Hausdorff and is compact, then is closed.
We show is open. Let . For each , the Hausdorff property yields disjoint open sets and . The collection is an open cover of . By compactness, there is a finite subcover .
Set . Then is open, , and . Since , we have , i.e., .
Thus is open, so is closed.
Combining the Results
In a compact Hausdorff space , a subset is compact if and only if is closed.
(): Compact in Hausdorff closed (Theorem 5.16).
(): Closed in compact compact (Theorem 5.15).
-
The set is compact in (closed and bounded by Heine-Borel, or directly: closed subset of ).
-
The Cantor set is compact (closed subset of a compact space).
-
The set is closed but not compact (closed but not bounded).
-
The set is not compact (not closed in ).
Without the Hausdorff assumption, compact subsets need not be closed. For example, in with the cofinite topology, every subset is compact (any open cover has a finite subcover since each complement is finite), but not every subset is closed. In this case, "compact closed" fails.
This is why many authors define compactness to include the Hausdorff condition (calling the general notion "quasi-compact"). We follow the convention where compactness does not imply Hausdorff, but many key theorems require both.