ProofComplete

Proof: Closed Subset of a Compact Space is Compact

This fundamental result states that a closed subset of a compact space inherits compactness. Combined with the fact that compact subsets of Hausdorff spaces are closed, it gives a complete characterization of compact subsets in compact Hausdorff spaces.


Statement

Theorem5.15Closed Subset of Compact is Compact

Let XX be a compact topological space and CXC \subseteq X a closed subset. Then CC is compact (in the subspace topology).


Proof via Open Covers

Proof

Let {Vα}αA\{V_\alpha\}_{\alpha \in A} be an open cover of CC. For each α\alpha, VαV_\alpha is open in the subspace topology on CC, so Vα=UαCV_\alpha = U_\alpha \cap C for some open set UαU_\alpha in XX.

Since CC is closed, XCX \setminus C is open in XX. Consider the collection: {Uα}αA{XC}.\{U_\alpha\}_{\alpha \in A} \cup \{X \setminus C\}.

This is an open cover of XX: For any xXx \in X, either xCx \in C (in which case xVα=UαCx \in V_\alpha = U_\alpha \cap C for some α\alpha, so xUαx \in U_\alpha) or xCx \notin C (so xXCx \in X \setminus C).

Extract a finite subcover: Since XX is compact, there exist α1,,αnA\alpha_1, \ldots, \alpha_n \in A such that: X=Uα1Uαn(XC).X = U_{\alpha_1} \cup \cdots \cup U_{\alpha_n} \cup (X \setminus C).

Restrict to CC: Intersecting both sides with CC: C=(Uα1C)(UαnC)((XC)C)==Vα1Vαn.C = (U_{\alpha_1} \cap C) \cup \cdots \cup (U_{\alpha_n} \cap C) \cup \underbrace{((X \setminus C) \cap C)}_{= \emptyset} = V_{\alpha_1} \cup \cdots \cup V_{\alpha_n}.

Therefore {Vα1,,Vαn}\{V_{\alpha_1}, \ldots, V_{\alpha_n}\} is a finite subcover of the original cover of CC, and CC is compact.


Alternative Proof via the FIP

Proof

We use the finite intersection property characterization. Let {Fβ}βB\{F_\beta\}_{\beta \in B} be a collection of closed subsets of CC (closed in the subspace topology) with the FIP. Since CC is closed in XX, each FβF_\beta is also closed in XX.

The collection {Fβ}\{F_\beta\} (viewed as subsets of XX) has the FIP: any finite intersection Fβ1FβnF_{\beta_1} \cap \cdots \cap F_{\beta_n} \neq \emptyset (this holds since FIP is the same regardless of the ambient space).

But wait: we need {Fβ}\{F_\beta\} together with CC to have the FIP in XX. Consider the collection {Fβ}β{C}\{F_\beta\}_{\beta} \cup \{C\} in XX. Each FβCF_\beta \subseteq C, so Fβ1FβnC=Fβ1FβnF_{\beta_1} \cap \cdots \cap F_{\beta_n} \cap C = F_{\beta_1} \cap \cdots \cap F_{\beta_n} \neq \emptyset. This collection has the FIP.

Since XX is compact, by the FIP characterization: (βBFβ)C=βBFβ\left(\bigcap_{\beta \in B} F_\beta\right) \cap C = \bigcap_{\beta \in B} F_\beta \neq \emptyset (the last equality since FβCF_\beta \subseteq C).

So Fβ\bigcap F_\beta \neq \emptyset, and CC is compact by the FIP characterization.


Converse and Complement

Theorem5.16Compact in Hausdorff Implies Closed

If XX is Hausdorff and KXK \subseteq X is compact, then KK is closed.

Proof

We show XKX \setminus K is open. Let xXKx \in X \setminus K. For each kKk \in K, the Hausdorff property yields disjoint open sets UkxU_k \ni x and VkkV_k \ni k. The collection {Vk}kK\{V_k\}_{k \in K} is an open cover of KK. By compactness, there is a finite subcover {Vk1,,Vkn}\{V_{k_1}, \ldots, V_{k_n}\}.

Set U=Uk1UknU = U_{k_1} \cap \cdots \cap U_{k_n}. Then UU is open, xUx \in U, and U(Vk1Vkn)=U \cap (V_{k_1} \cup \cdots \cup V_{k_n}) = \emptyset. Since KVk1VknK \subseteq V_{k_1} \cup \cdots \cup V_{k_n}, we have UK=U \cap K = \emptyset, i.e., UXKU \subseteq X \setminus K.

Thus XKX \setminus K is open, so KK is closed.


Combining the Results

Theorem5.17Compact Subsets of Compact Hausdorff Spaces

In a compact Hausdorff space XX, a subset KK is compact if and only if KK is closed.

Proof

(\Rightarrow): Compact in Hausdorff \Rightarrow closed (Theorem 5.16).

(\Leftarrow): Closed in compact \Rightarrow compact (Theorem 5.15).

ExampleApplications
  1. The set {1/n:nZ+}{0}\{1/n : n \in \mathbb{Z}^+\} \cup \{0\} is compact in R\mathbb{R} (closed and bounded by Heine-Borel, or directly: closed subset of [0,1][0, 1]).

  2. The Cantor set C[0,1]C \subseteq [0, 1] is compact (closed subset of a compact space).

  3. The set ZR\mathbb{Z} \subseteq \mathbb{R} is closed but not compact (closed but not bounded).

  4. The set (0,1)[0,1](0, 1) \subseteq [0, 1] is not compact (not closed in [0,1][0, 1]).

RemarkBeyond Hausdorff Spaces

Without the Hausdorff assumption, compact subsets need not be closed. For example, in R\mathbb{R} with the cofinite topology, every subset is compact (any open cover has a finite subcover since each complement is finite), but not every subset is closed. In this case, "compact \Rightarrow closed" fails.

This is why many authors define compactness to include the Hausdorff condition (calling the general notion "quasi-compact"). We follow the convention where compactness does not imply Hausdorff, but many key theorems require both.