Proof: Tychonoff's Theorem for Finite Products
We prove that a finite product of compact spaces is compact. This is the finite version of Tychonoff's theorem, which can be proved directly using the tube lemma without any appeal to Zorn's lemma or the axiom of choice.
The Tube Lemma
The key ingredient is the tube lemma, which controls how open sets in products behave near compact slices.
Let and be topological spaces with compact. If is an open set in containing the slice for some , then there exists an open set containing such that .
The set is called a tube about .
For each , the point . Since is open, there exist open sets and with .
The collection is an open cover of . Since is compact, there is a finite subcover .
Set . Then is open and (since for each ).
For any : since covers , we have for some . Then , so . Therefore .
Tychonoff for Two Factors
If and are compact topological spaces, then (with the product topology) is compact.
Let be an open cover of . We construct a finite subcover.
Step 1: For each , find a tube.
Fix . The slice is homeomorphic to (via the map ), hence compact. Since covers , there exist finitely many covering .
Set . Then is open and .
By the Tube Lemma, there exists an open set with and .
Step 2: Extract a finite subcover of .
The collection is an open cover of . Since is compact, there is a finite subcover .
Step 3: Combine.
For each , we have .
Since , the collection is a finite subcover of . (There are at most sets in this subcover.)
Therefore is compact.
Induction to Factors
If are compact spaces, then is compact.
By induction on . The base case is trivial.
For the inductive step, suppose is compact. There is a natural homeomorphism: (using associativity of the product topology). Since is compact by the inductive hypothesis and is compact, Theorem 3.13 gives that their product is compact.
Failure for Infinite Products Without Choice
The generalization of this result to arbitrary products is Tychonoff's theorem (Chapter 8): is compact (in the product topology) if and only if each is compact. The proof for infinite products requires the axiom of choice (or equivalently, Zorn's lemma). In fact, Tychonoff's theorem is equivalent to the axiom of choice (Kelley, 1950).
The finite version proved here requires no choice axiom whatsoever.
For any , the unit cube is compact, being a finite product of compact spaces. The unit interval is compact by the Heine-Borel theorem, and the finite Tychonoff theorem extends this to dimensions.
By the general Tychonoff theorem, the Hilbert cube is compact in the product topology. This is a metrizable compact space that contains a homeomorphic copy of every separable metrizable space.