ProofComplete

SYZ Conjecture and T-Duality - Key Proof

We outline McLean's proof that the moduli space of special Lagrangian deformations is smooth and unobstructed for tori in Calabi-Yau threefolds. This foundational result underpins the existence of SYZ fibrations.

ProofMcLean's Theorem on Special Lagrangian Moduli

Let LXL \subset X be a compact special Lagrangian nn-submanifold in a Calabi-Yau nn-fold (X,ω,Ω)(X, \omega, \Omega).

Step 1: Deformation Complex

Special Lagrangian deformations are infinitesimally described by normal vector fields νΓ(NL)\nu \in \Gamma(NL) satisfying: Im(Ω)(,Jν)=0\text{Im}(\Omega)(-, J\nu) = 0

where NLNL is the normal bundle and JJ is the complex structure.

The tangent space to the moduli space is: TLMSLag={ν:divL(ν)=0,Im(Ω)(,Jν)=0}T_L\mathcal{M}_{\text{SLag}} = \{\nu : \text{div}_L(\nu) = 0, \, \text{Im}(\Omega)(-, J\nu) = 0\}

Step 2: Identification with Cohomology

Using the Calabi-Yau structure, normal vectors can be identified with 1-forms on LL via: να=ιν(ωL)\nu \mapsto \alpha = \iota_\nu(\omega|_L)

The special Lagrangian condition Im(Ω)L=0\text{Im}(\Omega)|_L = 0 implies: dα=0(harmonicity)d\alpha = 0 \quad \text{(harmonicity)}

Thus: TLMSLagH1(L,R)T_L\mathcal{M}_{\text{SLag}} \cong H^1(L, \mathbb{R})

Step 3: Obstruction Theory

Obstructions to extending infinitesimal deformations lie in: H2(L,R)H^2(L, \mathbb{R})

For a 3-torus L=T3L = T^3 in a Calabi-Yau threefold, we have: H2(T3,R)=R3H^2(T^3, \mathbb{R}) = \mathbb{R}^3

However, the special Lagrangian equation is elliptic, and McLean shows obstructions vanish.

Step 4: Elliptic PDE Analysis

The special Lagrangian equation for a graph over LL with height function uu is: div(Du1+Du2)=H(u)\text{div}\left(\frac{Du}{\sqrt{1 + |Du|^2}}\right) = H(u)

where H(u)H(u) depends on the embedding. This is a fully nonlinear elliptic PDE.

The linearization at u=0u=0 is: ΔLv=0\Delta_L v = 0

The Fredholm theory for this operator gives:

  • Index = dimH1(L)dimH2(L)=b1(L)b2(L)\dim H^1(L) - \dim H^2(L) = b_1(L) - b_2(L)
  • For T3T^3: index =33=0= 3 - 3 = 0

Step 5: Smoothness via Implicit Function Theorem

The nonlinear operator: F:Ck,α(L)Ck2,α(L),uspecial Lagrangian equation(u)F: C^{k,\alpha}(L) \to C^{k-2,\alpha}(L), \quad u \mapsto \text{special Lagrangian equation}(u)

is smooth and has surjective linearization DF0=ΔLDF|_0 = \Delta_L. By the implicit function theorem for Banach spaces: F1(0)ker(DF0)=H1(L,R)F^{-1}(0) \cong \ker(DF|_0) = H^1(L, \mathbb{R})

near LL.

Step 6: Unobstructedness

The key observation is that for Calabi-Yau threefolds with L=T3L = T^3: H2(L,R)0but obstructions vanishH^2(L, \mathbb{R}) \neq 0 \quad \text{but obstructions vanish}

This follows from the fact that the obstruction map: O:H1(L)H1(L)H2(L)\mathcal{O}: H^1(L) \otimes H^1(L) \to H^2(L)

vanishes identically for special Lagrangians in Calabi-Yau manifolds.

Conclusion: The moduli space MSLag\mathcal{M}_{\text{SLag}} is smooth near LL with: dimMSLag=h1(L)=3\dim \mathcal{M}_{\text{SLag}} = h^1(L) = 3

for L=T3L = T^3.

Remark

This theorem is crucial for SYZ: it ensures that special Lagrangian T3T^3 fibers deform smoothly, allowing construction of families parametrized by the base BB. The dimension 3 matches the expected dimension of the SYZ base for Calabi-Yau threefolds.

For higher genus Lagrangians or non-Calabi-Yau ambient spaces, obstructions can be non-zero, making the moduli space singular or empty.

McLean's result provides the analytical foundation for SYZ, showing that the special Lagrangian condition is neither too restrictive (allowing deformations) nor too flexible (controlling the moduli space dimension).