TheoremComplete

Existence of Minimizers: Direct Method in the Calculus of Variations

Theorem7.2Tonelli's Theorem (Existence of Minimizers)

Let L(x,y,p)L(x,y,p) be continuous on [a,b]×R×R[a,b]\times\mathbb{R}\times\mathbb{R}, and suppose:

  1. Coercivity: L(x,y,p)αpr+βL(x,y,p) \geq \alpha|p|^r + \beta for some α>0\alpha > 0, r>1r > 1, and βR\beta\in\mathbb{R}.
  2. Convexity: pL(x,y,p)p \mapsto L(x,y,p) is convex for each fixed (x,y)(x,y).

Then the functional J[y]=abL(x,y(x),y(x))dxJ[y] = \int_a^b L(x,y(x),y'(x))\,dx attains its minimum on the Sobolev space W1,r([a,b])W^{1,r}([a,b]) subject to boundary conditions y(a)=Ay(a) = A, y(b)=By(b) = B. That is, there exists yW1,ry^* \in W^{1,r} with J[y]=inf{J[y]:y(a)=A,y(b)=B}J[y^*] = \inf\{J[y] : y(a)=A, y(b)=B\}.


Proof

Proof

The proof follows Tonelli's direct method in four steps.

Step 1: Boundedness below and minimizing sequence. Coercivity gives J[y]αabyrdx+β(ba)J[y] \geq \alpha\int_a^b|y'|^r\,dx + \beta(b-a), so JJ is bounded below. Let m=infJm = \inf J and choose a minimizing sequence {yn}\{y_n\} with J[yn]mJ[y_n] \to m.

Step 2: Uniform bounds. From J[yn]m+1J[y_n] \leq m + 1 (for large nn): αynLrrm+1β(ba)\alpha\|y_n'\|_{L^r}^r \leq m + 1 - \beta(b-a), giving uniform bounds on ynLr\|y_n'\|_{L^r}. Combined with the boundary condition yn(a)=Ay_n(a) = A, the Poincare inequality yields ynW1,rC\|y_n\|_{W^{1,r}} \leq C (uniform bound in Sobolev norm).

Step 3: Weak compactness. Since W1,r([a,b])W^{1,r}([a,b]) is reflexive for r>1r > 1 (as a closed subspace of LrL^r), the bounded sequence {yn}\{y_n\} has a weakly convergent subsequence: ynkyy_{n_k} \rightharpoonup y^* in W1,rW^{1,r}. By the Rellich-Kondrachov compactness theorem, ynkyy_{n_k} \to y^* strongly in C([a,b])C([a,b]) (and in LrL^r), so y(a)=Ay^*(a) = A and y(b)=By^*(b) = B.

Step 4: Lower semicontinuity. The key step: convexity of LL in pp implies weak lower semicontinuity of JJ. For each fixed (x,y)(x,y), convexity gives: L(x,y,p)L(x,y,q)+Lp(x,y,q)(pq)L(x,y,p) \geq L(x,y,q) + L_p(x,y,q)(p-q)

Integrating with q=(y)q = (y^*)' and p=ynp = y_n': J[yn]abL(x,yn,(y))dx+abLp(x,yn,(y))(yn(y))dxJ[y_n] \geq \int_a^b L(x,y_n,(y^*)')\,dx + \int_a^b L_p(x,y_n,(y^*)')\cdot(y_n'-(y^*)')\,dx

As nn\to\infty: the first integral converges to J[y]J[y^*] (by strong convergence of yny_n), and the second integral converges to 00 (by weak convergence of yny_n' tested against the LrL^{r'} function Lp(x,y,(y))L_p(x,y^*,(y^*)')). Therefore: m=limnJ[yn]J[y]mm = \lim_{n\to\infty} J[y_n] \geq J[y^*] \geq m

giving J[y]=mJ[y^*] = m. \square


ExampleApplication: Dirichlet's Principle

For J[u]=Ωu2dxJ[u] = \int_\Omega|\nabla u|^2\,dx (the Dirichlet energy), L=u2L = |\nabla u|^2 is strictly convex and coercive with r=2r=2. Tonelli's theorem guarantees a minimizer in H1(Ω)H^1(\Omega) with prescribed boundary values. The minimizer satisfies the Euler-Lagrange equation Δu=0\Delta u = 0 (Laplace's equation). This justifies Dirichlet's principle: the harmonic function with given boundary data minimizes the Dirichlet energy. Historically, Weierstrass showed that infimum need not be attained without the correct function space (the gap that Hilbert and Tonelli resolved).

RemarkFailure of Existence Without Convexity

Without convexity, minimizers may not exist. Consider J[y]=01(y21)2dxJ[y] = \int_0^1(y'^2-1)^2\,dx with y(0)=y(1)=0y(0)=y(1)=0. The infimum is 00 (approached by zigzag functions with y±1y' \approx \pm 1), but no smooth function achieves J=0J = 0 with these boundary conditions. The minimizing sequence develops increasingly rapid oscillations. Relaxation theory replaces LL by its quasiconvexification to restore existence in a generalized sense.