Proof: Universal Property Characterizes Tensor Product
We prove that the universal property uniquely characterizes the tensor product up to canonical isomorphism, justifying the categorical definition.
Theorem: If and both satisfy the universal property for the tensor product of and , then there exists a unique isomorphism making the diagram commute.
Proof:
Step 1: Apply universal property of to .
Since satisfies the universal property, the bilinear map induces a unique linear map such that:
Step 2: Apply universal property of to .
Similarly, since satisfies the universal property, the bilinear map induces a unique linear map such that:
Step 3: Compose to show .
Consider the composition . We have:
But the identity map also satisfies:
By uniqueness in the universal property of applied to the bilinear map itself, we must have:
Step 4: Similarly show .
Consider :
Also:
By uniqueness in the universal property of :
Step 5: Conclude is an isomorphism.
Since has two-sided inverse , it is an isomorphism. Moreover, is the unique map with by the universal property.
Conclusion: The tensor product is unique up to unique isomorphism. Any two constructions satisfying the universal property are canonically isomorphic. ∎
This proof exemplifies the power of universal properties in category theory. Rather than verifying isomorphism element-by-element, we use uniqueness built into the definition. The proof generalizes: any construction defined by a universal property is unique up to unique isomorphism. This principle appears throughout mathematics—free groups, quotient spaces, limits, colimits—establishing that "universal" constructions are well-defined invariants.
The uniqueness proof for tensor products validates treating as an abstract object characterized by its mapping property, independent of any specific construction (free modules, basis expansions, etc.). This abstraction is the foundation of modern algebra.