ProofComplete

Lie Algebras - Key Proof

We prove Engel's theorem, which characterizes nilpotent Lie algebras via the nilpotency of their adjoint operators. This proof illustrates important techniques in Lie algebra theory.

Proof

Engel's Theorem: Let g\mathfrak{g} be a finite-dimensional Lie algebra such that adX:gβ†’g\text{ad}_X: \mathfrak{g} \to \mathfrak{g} is nilpotent for every X∈gX \in \mathfrak{g}. Then g\mathfrak{g} is nilpotent.

Proof by induction on dimension:

Base case: If dim⁑g=1\dim \mathfrak{g} = 1, then g\mathfrak{g} is abelian, hence nilpotent.

Inductive step: Assume the result holds for all Lie algebras of dimension less than nn, and let dim⁑g=n\dim \mathfrak{g} = n.

Step 1: Find a proper ideal with nilpotent quotient.

Consider the set n={X∈g:adX is nilpotent}\mathfrak{n} = \{X \in \mathfrak{g} : \text{ad}_X \text{ is nilpotent}\}. By hypothesis, n=g\mathfrak{n} = \mathfrak{g}. We claim that there exists a proper ideal h\mathfrak{h} of g\mathfrak{g} such that g/h\mathfrak{g}/\mathfrak{h} is one-dimensional.

Step 2: Construct the ideal.

Consider the representation ad:g→gl(g)\text{ad}: \mathfrak{g} \to \mathfrak{gl}(\mathfrak{g}). Since all adX\text{ad}_X are nilpotent, we can apply the following lemma:

Lemma: If VV is a finite-dimensional vector space and g\mathfrak{g} acts on VV via nilpotent operators, then there exists a nonzero v∈Vv \in V such that Xβ‹…v=0X \cdot v = 0 for all X∈gX \in \mathfrak{g}.

Applying this lemma to V=gV = \mathfrak{g} with the adjoint action, there exists 0β‰ Y∈g0 \neq Y \in \mathfrak{g} such that [X,Y]=0[X, Y] = 0 for all X∈gX \in \mathfrak{g}. This means Y∈Z(g)Y \in Z(\mathfrak{g}), the center.

Step 3: Use the center.

Since Z(g)β‰ 0Z(\mathfrak{g}) \neq 0, choose a one-dimensional subspace h=FYβŠ†Z(g)\mathfrak{h} = \mathbb{F} Y \subseteq Z(\mathfrak{g}). This is an ideal because [X,Y]=0[X, Y] = 0 for all XX.

Step 4: Apply induction.

The quotient g/h\mathfrak{g}/\mathfrak{h} has dimension nβˆ’1n-1, and for any X+h∈g/hX + \mathfrak{h} \in \mathfrak{g}/\mathfrak{h}, the operator adX+h\text{ad}_{X + \mathfrak{h}} on g/h\mathfrak{g}/\mathfrak{h} is induced by adX\text{ad}_X on g\mathfrak{g}, hence is nilpotent.

By the inductive hypothesis, g/h\mathfrak{g}/\mathfrak{h} is nilpotent. Say the lower central series satisfies (g/h)k=0(\mathfrak{g}/\mathfrak{h})^{k} = 0 for some kk.

Step 5: Conclude g\mathfrak{g} is nilpotent.

The lower central series of g\mathfrak{g} satisfies: gkβŠ†h\mathfrak{g}^{k} \subseteq \mathfrak{h} Since hβŠ†Z(g)\mathfrak{h} \subseteq Z(\mathfrak{g}), we have: gk+1=[g,gk]βŠ†[g,h]=0\mathfrak{g}^{k+1} = [\mathfrak{g}, \mathfrak{g}^{k}] \subseteq [\mathfrak{g}, \mathfrak{h}] = 0

Therefore g\mathfrak{g} is nilpotent. β–‘

Proof of the Lemma: We prove by induction on dim⁑V\dim V. If dim⁑V=1\dim V = 1, any 0β‰ v∈V0 \neq v \in V works since nilpotent operators on a one-dimensional space must be zero.

For dim⁑V>1\dim V > 1, choose any proper subspace W⊊VW \subsetneq V that is g\mathfrak{g}-invariant (exists by induction on subalgebras). By induction, there exists 0β‰ w∈W0 \neq w \in W such that Xβ‹…w=0X \cdot w = 0 for all X∈gX \in \mathfrak{g}, or we apply to the quotient V/WV/W to find the required element. β–‘

β– 
Remark

Engel's theorem has important consequences: a Lie algebra g\mathfrak{g} is nilpotent if and only if the adjoint representation consists of nilpotent operators. This connects the abstract algebraic property (nilpotence of the lower central series) to a concrete linear-algebraic property (nilpotence of matrices).