Lie Algebras - Key Proof
We prove Engel's theorem, which characterizes nilpotent Lie algebras via the nilpotency of their adjoint operators. This proof illustrates important techniques in Lie algebra theory.
Engel's Theorem: Let be a finite-dimensional Lie algebra such that is nilpotent for every . Then is nilpotent.
Proof by induction on dimension:
Base case: If , then is abelian, hence nilpotent.
Inductive step: Assume the result holds for all Lie algebras of dimension less than , and let .
Step 1: Find a proper ideal with nilpotent quotient.
Consider the set . By hypothesis, . We claim that there exists a proper ideal of such that is one-dimensional.
Step 2: Construct the ideal.
Consider the representation . Since all are nilpotent, we can apply the following lemma:
Lemma: If is a finite-dimensional vector space and acts on via nilpotent operators, then there exists a nonzero such that for all .
Applying this lemma to with the adjoint action, there exists such that for all . This means , the center.
Step 3: Use the center.
Since , choose a one-dimensional subspace . This is an ideal because for all .
Step 4: Apply induction.
The quotient has dimension , and for any , the operator on is induced by on , hence is nilpotent.
By the inductive hypothesis, is nilpotent. Say the lower central series satisfies for some .
Step 5: Conclude is nilpotent.
The lower central series of satisfies: Since , we have:
Therefore is nilpotent. β‘
Proof of the Lemma: We prove by induction on . If , any works since nilpotent operators on a one-dimensional space must be zero.
For , choose any proper subspace that is -invariant (exists by induction on subalgebras). By induction, there exists such that for all , or we apply to the quotient to find the required element. β‘
Engel's theorem has important consequences: a Lie algebra is nilpotent if and only if the adjoint representation consists of nilpotent operators. This connects the abstract algebraic property (nilpotence of the lower central series) to a concrete linear-algebraic property (nilpotence of matrices).