TheoremComplete

Joyal Lifting Theorem

The Joyal lifting theorem establishes the existence of the Joyal model structure on sSet\mathbf{sSet} by characterizing its fibrations, trivial fibrations, and weak equivalences. It provides the key technical results needed to develop the theory of quasi-categories, including the characterization of categorical equivalences, the behavior of inner fibrations, and the lifting properties that make the theory work.


Main Results

Theorem3.1Joyal's existence theorem

The category sSet\mathbf{sSet} admits a left proper, cofibrantly generated model structure (the Joyal model structure) in which:

  1. The cofibrations are the monomorphisms.
  2. The fibrant objects are the quasi-categories.
  3. A map f:XYf: X \to Y between quasi-categories is a fibration if and only if it is an isofibration: an inner fibration such that every equivalence in YY lying over an object of XX lifts to an equivalence in XX.
  4. The weak equivalences between quasi-categories are the categorical equivalences: fully faithful and essentially surjective functors.
Theorem3.2Joyal lifting theorem for inner fibrations

Let p:XSp: X \to S be an inner fibration and let e:sse: s \to s' be an equivalence in SS (i.e., an isomorphism in the homotopy category hS\operatorname{h}S). Then for any lift sˉ\bar{s} of ss (i.e., p(sˉ)=sp(\bar{s}) = s), the equivalence ee lifts to an equivalence eˉ:sˉsˉ\bar{e}: \bar{s} \to \bar{s}' in XX with p(eˉ)=ep(\bar{e}) = e.

In other words, inner fibrations have the lifting property for equivalences, not just for inner horns.


Key Lemmas

ExampleFibers of inner fibrations

If p:XSp: X \to S is an inner fibration and sS0s \in S_0 is a vertex, the fiber Xs=p1(s)X_s = p^{-1}(s) is a quasi-category. This follows because inner horn fillers in XX lying over degenerate simplices in SS (at the vertex ss) provide inner horn fillers in XsX_s.

This shows that inner fibrations are indeed "families of quasi-categories."

ExampleEquivalence lifting property

The lifting theorem for equivalences is stronger than just lifting inner horns. It states that in an inner fibration p:CDp: \mathcal{C} \to \mathcal{D}, equivalences in D\mathcal{D} can always be lifted to equivalences in C\mathcal{C} (given a lift of the source).

This is the \infty-categorical analogue of the path-lifting property for covering spaces and fibrations. In an isofibration (Joyal fibration), the lift can be chosen to start at any specified point.

ExampleCharacterization of Joyal weak equivalences

A map f:CDf: \mathcal{C} \to \mathcal{D} between quasi-categories is a Joyal weak equivalence (categorical equivalence) if and only if:

  1. The induced functor hf:hChD\operatorname{h}f: \operatorname{h}\mathcal{C} \to \operatorname{h}\mathcal{D} on homotopy categories is an equivalence of ordinary categories.
  2. For all objects x,yCx, y \in \mathcal{C}, the induced map MapC(x,y)MapD(f(x),f(y))\operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal{C}}(x, y) \to \operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal{D}}(f(x), f(y)) is a weak homotopy equivalence.

Equivalently, ff is a categorical equivalence if it is essentially surjective (every object of D\mathcal{D} is equivalent to one in the image of ff) and fully faithful (the mapping space comparison is a weak equivalence).


Applications

ExampleFunctor categories are quasi-categories

A crucial consequence: if D\mathcal{D} is a quasi-category and KK is any simplicial set, then Fun(K,D)=DK\operatorname{Fun}(K, \mathcal{D}) = \mathcal{D}^K is a quasi-category. The proof uses the Joyal model structure: the exponential DK\mathcal{D}^K is fibrant (a quasi-category) whenever D\mathcal{D} is fibrant.

This justifies the use of functor categories throughout \infty-category theory without needing to verify the quasi-category axiom each time.

ExampleOver and under categories

For a quasi-category C\mathcal{C} and an object cCc \in \mathcal{C}, the overcategory (or slice) C/c\mathcal{C}_{/c} and undercategory Cc/\mathcal{C}_{c/} are quasi-categories. These are defined as simplicial sets with:

(C/c)n=Homc(Δ[n]Δ[0],C)(\mathcal{C}_{/c})_n = \operatorname{Hom}_c(\Delta[n] \star \Delta[0], \mathcal{C})

The Joyal lifting theorem ensures that the forgetful functor C/cC\mathcal{C}_{/c} \to \mathcal{C} is a right fibration, and the forgetful functor Cc/C\mathcal{C}_{c/} \to \mathcal{C} is a left fibration.

ExampleFoundation for straightening/unstraightening

The Joyal model structure and lifting theorem provide the foundation for Lurie's straightening/unstraightening equivalence:

St:sSet/Sleft fib    Fun(S,S):Un\operatorname{St}: \mathbf{sSet}_{/S}^{\text{left fib}} \xrightarrow{\;\simeq\;} \operatorname{Fun}(S, \mathcal{S}): \operatorname{Un}

This equivalence identifies left fibrations XSX \to S with functors SSS \to \mathcal{S} (from SS to the \infty-category of spaces). It is the \infty-categorical Grothendieck construction and is fundamental to the entire theory.

The Joyal lifting theorem ensures that the fibers of a left fibration are Kan complexes (spaces), making this identification possible.

ExampleComparison with other models

The Joyal model structure on sSet\mathbf{sSet} is Quillen equivalent to:

  • The Bergner model structure on simplicial categories (via the coherent nerve NΔCN_\Delta \dashv \mathfrak{C}).
  • The Rezk model structure on bisimplicial sets (complete Segal spaces).
  • The Segal category model structure.

These Quillen equivalences show that quasi-categories, simplicial categories, complete Segal spaces, and Segal categories all provide equivalent models for (,1)(\infty, 1)-categories.

ExampleExistence of limits and colimits

The Joyal model structure provides the technical foundation for proving that quasi-categories have limits and colimits. Specifically:

  • Representability: A functor F:KCF: K \to \mathcal{C} has a limit if and only if the canonical map CFun(K,C)\mathcal{C} \to \operatorname{Fun}(K, \mathcal{C}) has a right adjoint.
  • Construction: Limits in C\mathcal{C} are computed as terminal objects of the appropriate slice category C/F\mathcal{C}_{/F}.

The lifting properties of isofibrations are essential for establishing the universal properties of these constructions.


Historical Notes

RemarkHistory

The Joyal model structure was introduced by Andre Joyal in his unpublished manuscript "Quasi-categories and Kan complexes" (circa 2002) and his notes on "The Theory of Quasi-categories" (2008). The existence proof is technically demanding, requiring careful analysis of the combinatorics of inner horn fillers and the behavior of categorical equivalences.

Joyal's work built on the earlier observation by Boardman--Vogt (1973) that weak Kan complexes (quasi-categories) provide a model for homotopy-coherent categories. Lurie's "Higher Topos Theory" (2009) developed the full theory of \infty-categories using the Joyal model structure as its foundation.


Summary

RemarkKey points

The Joyal lifting theorem and model structure provide the technical foundation for \infty-category theory:

  1. The Joyal model structure has quasi-categories as fibrant objects and categorical equivalences as weak equivalences.

  2. Inner fibrations have the lifting property for equivalences, making fibers into quasi-categories.

  3. Isofibrations (Joyal fibrations) additionally lift equivalences starting at specified points.

  4. The model structure is Quillen equivalent to simplicial categories, complete Segal spaces, and Segal categories.

  5. It provides the foundation for functor categories, slice categories, limits/colimits, and the straightening/unstraightening equivalence.