ProofComplete

Noetherian Rings and Modules - Key Proof

We prove Hilbert's Basis Theorem, the foundational result ensuring polynomial rings over Noetherian rings are Noetherian.

TheoremHilbert's Basis Theorem

If RR is Noetherian, then R[x]R[x] is Noetherian.

ProofProof of Hilbert's Basis Theorem

Let IβŠ†R[x]I \subseteq R[x] be an ideal. We must show II is finitely generated.

For each nβ‰₯0n \geq 0, define: In={a∈R:thereΒ existsΒ f∈IΒ ofΒ degree ≀nΒ withΒ leadingΒ coefficientΒ a}βˆͺ{0}I_n = \{a \in R : \text{there exists } f \in I \text{ of degree } \leq n \text{ with leading coefficient } a\} \cup \{0\}

Claim 1: Each InI_n is an ideal of RR.

If a,b∈Ina, b \in I_n with polynomials f,g∈If, g \in I of degrees ≀n\leq n having leading coefficients a,ba, b, then (adjusting degrees): xnβˆ’deg⁑ff+xnβˆ’deg⁑gg∈Ix^{n-\deg f}f + x^{n-\deg g}g \in I has degree ≀n\leq n and leading coefficient a+ba + b. Similarly, for r∈Rr \in R, the polynomial rfrf has leading coefficient rara, so ra∈Inra \in I_n.

Claim 2: We have I0βŠ†I1βŠ†I2βŠ†β‹―I_0 \subseteq I_1 \subseteq I_2 \subseteq \cdots.

If a∈Ina \in I_n via polynomial ff of degree ≀n\leq n, then xfxf has degree ≀n+1\leq n+1 with leading coefficient aa, so a∈In+1a \in I_{n+1}.

Claim 3: Since RR is Noetherian, the chain stabilizes: IN=IN+1=β‹―I_N = I_{N+1} = \cdots for some NN.

Step 4: For each n≀Nn \leq N, choose finitely many generators an,1,…,an,kna_{n,1}, \ldots, a_{n,k_n} for InI_n (possible since RR is Noetherian). For each an,ia_{n,i}, choose fn,i∈If_{n,i} \in I of degree ≀n\leq n with leading coefficient an,ia_{n,i}.

Let JJ be the ideal generated by all fn,if_{n,i} for 0≀n≀N0 \leq n \leq N. This is a finite set, so JJ is finitely generated. Clearly JβŠ†IJ \subseteq I.

Step 5: We prove IβŠ†JI \subseteq J by induction on degree.

Base case: If f∈If \in I has degree 00 (constant), then f∈I0f \in I_0, so f=βˆ‘ria0,if = \sum r_i a_{0,i} for some ri∈Rr_i \in R. Thus f=βˆ‘rif0,i∈Jf = \sum r_i f_{0,i} \in J.

Inductive step: Suppose f∈If \in I has degree d>0d > 0 with leading coefficient aa.

If d≀Nd \leq N: Then a∈Ida \in I_d, so a=βˆ‘riad,ia = \sum r_i a_{d,i} for ri∈Rr_i \in R. Consider: g=fβˆ’βˆ‘rifd,ig = f - \sum r_i f_{d,i}

Each fd,if_{d,i} has degree ≀d\leq d, so after adjustment, g∈Ig \in I has degree <d< d. By induction, g∈Jg \in J, so f=g+βˆ‘rifd,i∈Jf = g + \sum r_i f_{d,i} \in J.

If d>Nd > N: Then a∈Id=INa \in I_d = I_N, so a=βˆ‘riaN,ia = \sum r_i a_{N,i}. Consider: g=fβˆ’βˆ‘rixdβˆ’NfN,ig = f - \sum r_i x^{d-N} f_{N,i}

This polynomial has degree <d< d (the leading term cancels). By induction, g∈Jg \in J, so f∈Jf \in J.

Therefore I=JI = J is finitely generated, so R[x]R[x] is Noetherian.

β– 
Remark

The proof uses a clever "coefficient ideal" construction, reducing the polynomial problem to ideal generation in RR. The stabilization of the chain {In}\{I_n\} is crucial, exploiting the Noetherian hypothesis directly.

ProofCorollary: Multivariate Version

By induction, if RR is Noetherian, then R[x1,…,xn]=R[x1][x2]β‹―[xn]R[x_1, \ldots, x_n] = R[x_1][x_2]\cdots[x_n] is Noetherian, since each single-variable extension preserves the property.

β– 
ExampleApplication

For kk a field, k[x1,…,xn]k[x_1, \ldots, x_n] is Noetherian since kk is trivially Noetherian. Every ideal in polynomial rings over fields is finitely generated, the foundation of computational algebraic geometry (GrΓΆbner bases).

ProofPower Series Variant

A similar proof shows R[[x]]R[[x]] is Noetherian when RR is. The key difference: for power series, "leading coefficient" means the first non-zero coefficient, and degree is replaced by order.

The construction of InI_n uses series with order β‰₯n\geq n, and stabilization again comes from the Noetherian property of RR.

β– 
Remark

Hilbert's original 1890 proof used different techniques involving invariant theory. The modern ideal-theoretic proof, essentially due to Noether and subsequent algebraists, clarifies the structural reason for finiteness: ascending chains in RR control polynomial generation.

This proof establishes one of commutative algebra's most important theorems, ensuring Noetherian properties extend to all natural polynomial constructions.