TheoremComplete

Burnside's Theorem on Groups of Order paqbp^a q^b

Burnside's theorem shows that groups whose order involves only two prime factors are always solvable, a result whose original proof was a landmark application of representation theory to group theory.


Statement

Theorem10.6Burnside's $p^a q^b$ theorem

Let GG be a finite group with ∣G∣=paqb|G| = p^a q^b where p,qp, q are primes and a,b≥0a, b \geq 0. Then GG is solvable.


Proof Outline (using representation theory)

Proof

The proof uses character theory. We outline the key steps.

Step 1 (Burnside's lemma on conjugacy classes): If χ\chi is an irreducible character of GG with gcd⁡(χ(1),∣C∣)=1\gcd(\chi(1), |C|) = 1 for some conjugacy class CC, and g∈Cg \in C with g≠eg \neq e, then either χ(g)=0\chi(g) = 0 or ∣χ(g)∣=χ(1)|\chi(g)| = \chi(1) (in which case g∈Z(ρ(G))g \in Z(\rho(G)) for the corresponding representation ρ\rho).

Step 2: If GG is a non-abelian simple group of order paqbp^a q^b, consider a conjugacy class CC with ∣C∣=pk|C| = p^k (such a class exists since not all classes have size divisible by qq). Every irreducible character χ\chi with p∤χ(1)p \nmid \chi(1) satisfies gcd⁡(χ(1),∣C∣)=1\gcd(\chi(1), |C|) = 1, so by Step 1, either χ(g)=0\chi(g) = 0 or g∈ker⁡ρg \in \ker \rho. Since GG is simple, ker⁡ρ={e}\ker \rho = \{e\} or GG.

Step 3: Using the column orthogonality relation ∑χ∣χ(g)∣2=∣CG(g)∣\sum_\chi |\chi(g)|^2 = |C_G(g)| and the fact from Step 2, derive that gg acts trivially in too many representations, leading to g=eg = e -- a contradiction.

Therefore no non-abelian simple group has order paqbp^a q^b, meaning any group of order paqbp^a q^b has a nontrivial normal subgroup. By induction on ∣G∣|G|, both the normal subgroup and the quotient are solvable, hence GG is solvable. ■\blacksquare

■

Significance

RemarkElementary proofs

Burnside's original proof (1904) was one of the first applications of representation theory. An elementary (purely group-theoretic) proof was not found until 1972 by Goldschmidt (for p=2p=2) and completed by Bender and others. This illustrates the power of representation-theoretic methods: they can prove results that are extremely difficult to obtain by direct combinatorial arguments.

ExampleApplications
  • Groups of order 12=22⋅312 = 2^2 \cdot 3: solvable by Burnside. Indeed, A4,D6,Z/12A_4, D_6, \mathbb{Z}/12, etc., are all solvable.
  • Groups of order 200=23⋅52200 = 2^3 \cdot 5^2: solvable.
  • The smallest non-solvable group A5A_5 has order 60=22⋅3⋅560 = 2^2 \cdot 3 \cdot 5, involving three primes.
RemarkConnection to the classification

Burnside's theorem is a stepping stone to the Feit-Thompson theorem (1963): every group of odd order is solvable. This 255-page proof is one of the landmarks leading to the classification of finite simple groups.