TheoremComplete

Burnside's Theorem on Groups of Order paqbp^a q^b

Burnside's theorem shows that groups whose order involves only two prime factors are always solvable, a result whose original proof was a landmark application of representation theory to group theory.


Statement

Theorem10.6Burnside's $p^a q^b$ theorem

Let GG be a finite group with G=paqb|G| = p^a q^b where p,qp, q are primes and a,b0a, b \geq 0. Then GG is solvable.


Proof Outline (using representation theory)

Proof

The proof uses character theory. We outline the key steps.

Step 1 (Burnside's lemma on conjugacy classes): If χ\chi is an irreducible character of GG with gcd(χ(1),C)=1\gcd(\chi(1), |C|) = 1 for some conjugacy class CC, and gCg \in C with geg \neq e, then either χ(g)=0\chi(g) = 0 or χ(g)=χ(1)|\chi(g)| = \chi(1) (in which case gZ(ρ(G))g \in Z(\rho(G)) for the corresponding representation ρ\rho).

Step 2: If GG is a non-abelian simple group of order paqbp^a q^b, consider a conjugacy class CC with C=pk|C| = p^k (such a class exists since not all classes have size divisible by qq). Every irreducible character χ\chi with pχ(1)p \nmid \chi(1) satisfies gcd(χ(1),C)=1\gcd(\chi(1), |C|) = 1, so by Step 1, either χ(g)=0\chi(g) = 0 or gkerρg \in \ker \rho. Since GG is simple, kerρ={e}\ker \rho = \{e\} or GG.

Step 3: Using the column orthogonality relation χχ(g)2=CG(g)\sum_\chi |\chi(g)|^2 = |C_G(g)| and the fact from Step 2, derive that gg acts trivially in too many representations, leading to g=eg = e -- a contradiction.

Therefore no non-abelian simple group has order paqbp^a q^b, meaning any group of order paqbp^a q^b has a nontrivial normal subgroup. By induction on G|G|, both the normal subgroup and the quotient are solvable, hence GG is solvable. \blacksquare


Significance

RemarkElementary proofs

Burnside's original proof (1904) was one of the first applications of representation theory. An elementary (purely group-theoretic) proof was not found until 1972 by Goldschmidt (for p=2p=2) and completed by Bender and others. This illustrates the power of representation-theoretic methods: they can prove results that are extremely difficult to obtain by direct combinatorial arguments.

ExampleApplications
  • Groups of order 12=22312 = 2^2 \cdot 3: solvable by Burnside. Indeed, A4,D6,Z/12A_4, D_6, \mathbb{Z}/12, etc., are all solvable.
  • Groups of order 200=2352200 = 2^3 \cdot 5^2: solvable.
  • The smallest non-solvable group A5A_5 has order 60=223560 = 2^2 \cdot 3 \cdot 5, involving three primes.
RemarkConnection to the classification

Burnside's theorem is a stepping stone to the Feit-Thompson theorem (1963): every group of odd order is solvable. This 255-page proof is one of the landmarks leading to the classification of finite simple groups.