TheoremComplete

Existence and Uniqueness of Algebraic Closures

Every field has an algebraic closure, and any two algebraic closures are isomorphic. This result provides the "universal" field in which all polynomial equations can be solved.


Statement

Theorem7.7Existence of algebraic closure

For every field FF, there exists an algebraically closed field F\overline{F} containing FF such that F/F\overline{F}/F is algebraic. Moreover, any two algebraic closures of FF are FF-isomorphic.


Proof of Existence (Artin's proof)

Proof

Step 1: For each monic non-constant fF[x]f \in F[x], introduce a variable xfx_f. Form the polynomial ring S=F[{xf:fF[x],degf1}]S = F[\{x_f : f \in F[x],\, \deg f \geq 1\}] and the ideal I=(f(xf):fF[x],degf1)I = (f(x_f) : f \in F[x],\, \deg f \geq 1).

Step 2: ISI \neq S. If 1I1 \in I, then 1=gifi(xfi)1 = \sum g_i f_i(x_{f_i}) for finitely many f1,,fkf_1, \ldots, f_k. The product h=f1fkh = f_1 \cdots f_k has a splitting field KK, and evaluating at roots gives 1=01 = 0 in KK, a contradiction.

Step 3: Since ISI \neq S, extend II to a maximal ideal mI\mathfrak{m} \supseteq I (by Zorn's lemma). Set F1=S/mF_1 = S/\mathfrak{m}, which is a field extension of FF in which every fF[x]f \in F[x] has a root.

Step 4: Iterate: FF1F2F \subset F_1 \subset F_2 \subset \cdots where each Fn+1F_{n+1} is constructed from FnF_n so that every polynomial over FnF_n has a root in Fn+1F_{n+1}. Set F=n=0Fn\overline{F} = \bigcup_{n=0}^{\infty} F_n.

Every polynomial over F\overline{F} has coefficients in some FnF_n, hence has a root in Fn+1FF_{n+1} \subseteq \overline{F}. By induction on degree, every polynomial splits completely. So F\overline{F} is algebraically closed.

The extension F/F\overline{F}/F is algebraic: every element of FnF_n is a root of a polynomial over Fn1F_{n-1}, and by induction, a root of a polynomial over FF. \blacksquare


Uniqueness

Theorem7.8Uniqueness (Steinitz)

If F\overline{F} and F\overline{F}' are two algebraic closures of FF, then there exists an isomorphism σ:FF\sigma: \overline{F} \to \overline{F}' fixing FF. This isomorphism is generally not unique -- the non-uniqueness is captured by the absolute Galois group Gal(F/F)\mathrm{Gal}(\overline{F}/F).

ExampleAlgebraic closures
  • R=C\overline{\mathbb{R}} = \mathbb{C} (by the fundamental theorem of algebra).
  • Q=\overline{\mathbb{Q}} = the field of algebraic numbers, a countable subfield of C\mathbb{C}.
  • Fp=n1Fpn\overline{\mathbb{F}_p} = \bigcup_{n \geq 1} \mathbb{F}_{p^n}, a countably infinite field.
  • Qp\overline{\mathbb{Q}_p} (algebraic closure of the pp-adic numbers) is not complete; its completion is Cp\mathbb{C}_p.
RemarkThe absolute Galois group

Gal(F/F)\mathrm{Gal}(\overline{F}/F) is the group of all FF-automorphisms of F\overline{F}. For F=QF = \mathbb{Q}, this is an enormously complicated profinite group that encodes all of algebraic number theory. Understanding Gal(Q/Q)\mathrm{Gal}(\overline{\mathbb{Q}}/\mathbb{Q}) is one of the deepest open problems in mathematics, connected to the Langlands program and inverse Galois problem.